Showing posts with label transparency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label transparency. Show all posts

Dealing with Corruption in Haiti

Seconds after the Chile tremors subsided, the comparisons began: Haiti suffers a category 7.0 earthquake and well over 200,000 die (President Rene Preval recently has been predicting 300,000 as the final toll ). Chile experiences a category 8.8 quake--roughly 500 times stronger than Haiti's--and the death toll hovers at less than 200. In the last few days, I have read multiple variations on this theme, and you know what surprises me? That anyone is surprised.

The very idea that a middle income country like Chile, with its strong building codes, low level of perceived corruption, and responsive government could be compared with Haiti is just ludicrous. Chile is a Latin American "dream" poised to become the first OECD member from that region, and Haiti is widely regarded as the poorest country in the Hemisphere. Is it so surprising that their experience of any catastrophe would be vastly different? (Not to mention, of course, that Haiti's earthquake centered around its densely populated capital, while Chile's hit its more remote outer region.) It seems to me the more relevant question is this: How do we help prepare Haiti for the next inevitable crisis?

Experts credit Portugal's 1755 earthquake--which demolished the city of Lisbon, killed as many as 40,000 residents, and precipitated multiple fires and a devastating tsunami--as "the first modern disaster." Citizens demanded change in the way government prepared for and responded to natural disasters. As a result, Portugal reconstructed Lisbon with the zeal of the newly converted: a scientific inquiry into the mechanics of earthquakes was launched, strict zoning rules were passed, and Portugal became the first country in Europe to adopt building codes for seismic activity. In short, Portugal's 1755 catastrophe became the vehicle for change. Is that likely to happen to Haiti as well? Probably not.

The US Geological Survey recently predicted even more seismic activity in the region. There is no question that Haiti (and the island of Hispanola) is likely to experience further significant tremors. But rather than allowing the information to galvanize them into action, the Haitian government is engaged in more of its business-as-usual antics. The Washington Post reported President Rene Preval interrupted a high-level meeting with Admiral Mike Mullen, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, to chide Post reporters for publishing stories of government corruption. "There is no corruption here," Preval reportedly declared. "We have a high sense of morality." Preval is either woefully uninformed or simply unwilling to tackle a serious problem that threatens Haiti's future.

Transparency International ranks Haiti 168 out of 180 countries in terms of the level of perceived corruption of the country's public sector (Chile is ranked 25). Preval might believe there is no corruption, but Haiti's international business partners would respectfully disagree. Indeed, even as Preval was adopting his "no corruption here" mantra, stories abounded of Haitian customs officials demanding humanitarian organizations pay exorbitant "taxes" on donated goods entering the country to aid the millions of displaced Haitians. It seems even in the midst of this epic crisis, the Ministry of Economy and Finance found the time to adopt a new set of procedure for getting supplies into the country: Organizations now were to sign over the goods to the Haitian Department of Civil Protection, which would review their request to get a tax exemption before releasing the goods. The rationale for this new, onerous procedure? To prevent businesses from sneaking in goods tax free under the banner of relief agencies. Ministry officials quickly denied they were taxing humanitarian goods. But for organizations who have volunteered a week or two of service to Haiti, the burdensome new procedures simply ensure the work they went to do would not get done.

There is no great mystery here. We know how to rebuild Haiti's infrastructure to avoid the kind of catastrophic outcome that occurred on January 12: Adopt strong building codes and land use planning procedures that avoid building in hazardous areas, and appoint government agents to ensure compliance. Chile (and Portugal) has shown us the way. But none of that is likely to happen until Haiti's pervasive corruption is resolved . . . or at least circumvented.

Why not appoint an authority responsible for overseeing Haiti's rebuilding effort (I admit here that I am building on a proposal offered up by another at a wonderful conference on Haiti hosted by California State University Sacramento last week)? The authority would be composed of Haitian government officials, to be sure, but also Haitian businesses and citizens, NGOs, and international donors, all of whom have an ultimate stake in the outcome. Who would demand that Haiti establish such an authority? Certainly the Haitian people should, but Haiti's government is not susceptible to the popular will. The international community, which is bringing in millions of dollars to sustain Haiti, does have the clout to demand the creation of such an authority. We should use it.

The Haitian earthquake is a catastrophe of unfathomable proportions. It should serve as a galvanizing force for change in the way Haiti has functioned. This cannot happen without a fundamental shift in the way Haiti does business. We need change.

Lawyer regulation in Europe & at home

First of all, let me extend my thanks to IntLawGrrls for encouraging me to appear as a guest blogger. Although I have extensive materials posted on the Internet, I usually am very shy about blogging. As a result, I was very appreciative of the encouragement that IntLawGrrl Diane Marie Amann gave me to serve as a guest blogger, especially since my international law “niche” is not very well known.
I think there are a couple of reasons why my “niche” is not well-known:
► First, relatively few scholars work in this field.
► Second, for many years, the topics I have written about weren’t addressed at American Society of International Law or International Law Association meetings.
► Third, this field doesn’t’ fit neatly into the boxes of public international law or private international law. Indeed, early on, it wasn’t always clear that what I did was “law.”
I am deeply committed to transparency, and many of my early articles memorialized and analyzed bar association initiatives related to lawyer regulation. As time has marched on, many of these initiatives have become “law” and have provided the foundation for international or transnational legal developments. Because these initiatives often were developed by volunteer lawyers who had day jobs, I considered it a great success to get the developments out of their file cabinets (later, their computers) and into the public domain, where the initiatives could be shared, analyzed, and debated.
I still consider myself a transparency crusader. But much of what I now do is sift through voluminous Internet websites in order to synthesize, publicize, and spur public debate about important developments in the regulation of global lawyers.
An example of this scholarship is my article entitled "The European Commission Project Regarding Competition in Professional Services," published this year in the Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business.
Many international lawyers have now heard about the Clementi Report, which provided the impetus for the reforms in Britain's Legal Services Act 2007, which has dramatically changed the regulation of the legal profession in England and Wales and has set the stage to allow allow publicly traded law firms in the United Kingdom. (They already exist in Australia.)
Most lawyers are not aware, however, that a similar initiative exists in the European Union, and that it too has led to wide-ranging reform proposals.
In 2002, Wouters (Case C-309/99) and Arduino (Case C-35/99), both involving competition law (in the United States, antitrust law) and the legal profession, were pending before the European Court of Justice. At this time the European Commission issued an “invitation to tender” a study of the liberal professions; the resulting contract was awarded to the Institut für Höhere Studien/Institute for Advanced Studies in Vienna, known by the acronym IHS. In March 2003, the European Commission: announced the results of the IHS Study; launched a professional services competition initiative that would focus on several professions, including the legal profession; and began a Stocktaking Exercise. The IHS Study included the figure below, which was very influential:
(In this table, the darker the color and the higher the number, the more regulation a country has.) The Study concluded that countries with lower levels of regulation did not have higher levels of consumer complaints, and questioned whether higher levels of regulation were necessary.
In 2004, the Commission issued its Report on Competition in Professional Services. For the legal services sector, this Report, like the IHS Study, examined 5 issues:
► lawyer qualification, or entry, rules;
► lawyer monopoly rules;
► alternative business structure prohibitions, such as prohibitions on publicly traded law firms and multidisciplinary partnerships;
► fee rules; and
► advertising rules.
The Commission’s 2004 Report relied heavily on the IHS study. Among other things, the former asked whether

the lower regulation strategies which work in one Member State might be made to work in another, without decreasing the quality of professional services, and for the ultimate benefit of the consumer.
In 2005, the Commission issued a followup report, Professional Services -- Scope for more reform, which stated that the Commission was “fully committed to bringing about wide scale reform to this sector.” Paragraph 25 of the Report contained some damning language about the current lawyer regulatory system:

The weight of tradition should not be underestimated as affecting the pace of change, and in many countries regulators fail to see how things can be done differently. Moreover, the professions themselves have in general not been actively promoting it. The current picture could also indicate that some countries have relatively weak regulatory oversight of the professions. This could be caused by the economic phenomenon of regulatory capture which is not uncommon especially in areas subject to self-regulation.

The 2005 followup report used an updated version of a chart that had appeared in the IHS study to bolster its conclusion about the need for regulatory reforms:
Although the Commission seems subsequently to have changed some of its competition enforcement priorities, these reports remain influential for several reasons:
►First, many European Union member states are now engaged in reviewing (and sometimes dramatically changing) their lawyer regulatory rules.
►Second, these reports (or the underlying IHS study) have been relied upon in several subsequent global initiatives, including the 2008 Report on Competitive Restrictions in Legal Professions of the Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development, as well as the OECD's Indicators of Regulatory Conditions in the Professional Services.
►Third, the American Bar Association's creation of a Commission on Ethics 20/20, coupled with the likely adoption of rules that will allow publicly traded law firms in Britain, the issues addressed in these reports remain very topical.

In my view, because of the crucial roles lawyers play in developing international law and in preserving the rule of law, these developments are important for all international lawyers and scholars, regardless of their areas of specialization. This EU initiative addresses infrastructure issues that determine how lawyers are able to go about doing their jobs.
My article discusses the IHS Study, the Commission reports, stakeholder responses, related developments, and possible implications. It is a lengthy article because, as noted earlier, it was intended to synthesize, publicize, and spur public debate about this very important global lawyer regulatory development. My shorter, more reflective article on the significance of the EU Professional Services Initiative, along with a number of other developments, is here; my Powerpoint slide version may be found here.
Thanks again for inviting me to serve as a guest blogger. I hope this post has provided something a bit different, but interesting.

One small step for immigrants . . .

While the economic crisis may have pushed President Obama's plans for comprehensive immigration reform into next year and beyond, Democrats in the legislature are already offering a preview of good news for immigrants. Moreover, given the vast discretion awarded to the executive in enforcing immigration law, we may see a sea change in the treatment of immigrants before any immigration reform bill hits the floor of the legislature.
This Wednesday, Senator Leahy held a Judiciary Committee meeting to discuss the Uniting American Families Act of 2009, a bill that would extend those immigration benefits currently offered to married heterosexual couples to "permanent partners." The latter are defined as individuals over 18 years of age in a monogamous, financially interdependent relationship intended to be a lifelong commitment, but unable to marry. This amendment would thus allow an LGBT U.S. citizen in permanent partnership with a non-citizen to sponsor her partner for a green card and an LGBT asylee or refugee to designate his partner as a derivative recipient of his asylum or refugee status, among other benefits. The impact on LGBT couples would be tremendous, but of course, as the NY Times describes, political opponents have already reacted strongly. This will not be one of those "areas of agreement" that Obama seeks to identify; brace yourselves for a long, hard fight -- but at least it's being fought.
On the same day, Attorney General Holder confirmed that non-citizens are entitled to effective assistance of counsel in immigration hearings. This wise step vacated former AG Mukasey's decision in Matter of Compean (about which IntLawGrrl Dina Francesca Haynes posted here), less than two weeks before Obama took office, to overturn long-standing precedent establishing a framework for bringing ineffective assistance of counsel claims in immigration court. Bringing great cheer to the hearts of immigrants and proceduralists alike, Holder notes that the process used by Mukasey to overturn the ineffective assistance of counsel framework was insufficient, and seeks instead to create

one that affords all interested parties a full and fair opportunity to participate and ensures that the relevant facts and analysis are collected and evaluated.

(In the meantime, the pre-Compean framework remains in place.) While this standard may seem a bare minimum of procedural fairness, it represents a great step towards transparency and fairness in an area of law heretofore characterized by neither. Here's hoping it's the first of many such steps.

Time for US to move toward accountability

(My thanks to IntLawGrrls for the opportunity to guest-post on an issue of special importance to the NGO for which I am Executive Director, the Center for Justice and Accountability)

Last week, President Obama released four declassified memos written by the Office of Legal Counsel under the Bush administration. These memos provided a legal framework for the torture of detainees held by the CIA in connection with the "War on Terror." (Prior IntLawGrrls posts here, here, and here.)
The contents of the memos are spine-chilling. Government lawyers employed strained legal reasoning to eviscerate the definition of torture under international and domestic U.S. law. In effect, these memos gave the imprimatur of the U.S. Justice Department to abhorrent and illegal acts. The memos authorized interrogators:
► to slam a prisoner's head against a wall repeatedly;
► to deprive prisoners of sleep for eleven days at a time; and even
► to subject prisoners to "waterboarding," a technique of controlled suffocation that was used extensively by the Spanish Inquisition and by the Khmer Rouge during the genocide in Cambodia. As a result of these legal opinions, one prisoner was waterboarded 183 times.
In one of the memos, Steven G. Bradbury, then Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General, opines on what constitutes "prolonged mental harm" as a result of torture. In doing so, he cites to Mehinovic v. Vuckovic, CJA's case against a Bosnian torturer Nikola Vuckovic. Bradbury juxtaposes waterboarding, which is used to "induce a sensation of drowning," with the game of "Russian roulette," which CJA clients Kemal Mehinovic, Muhamed Bicic, Safet Hadzialijagic and Hasan Subasic experienced while being held in a Bosnian detention camp. Strangely, Bradbury concludes that that waterboarding is an acceptable form of torture, but "Russian roulette" is not. Needless to say, CJA's clients who have been subjected to waterboarding would disagree.
In the statement accompanying the release of these memos, President Obama stated that he believes strongly in "transparency and accountability." Certainly, transparency is a virtue, and more light must be shed on the torture program outlined in these memos. But transparency alone will not serve to deter torture unless it is followed by accountability. The disclosure of these memos is only the first step in ensuring that the United States will never again violate the prohibition against torture.
It is time to make the next step.
In order to hold the authors of these memos accountable, CJA joins human rights groups around the world in calling on Congress and the Obama administration to investigate and, if warranted, prosecute U.S. officials responsible for torture. Those held responsible should include:
► the interrogators who committed torture,
► the lawyers and senior officials who authorized torture, and
► the medical personnel who oversaw torture.
Investigating torture is not only our moral duty: it is our legal obligation. When the U.S. Senate ratified the Convention Against Torture in 1994, we committed ourselves as a nation not only to refrain from torture but to prosecute perpetrators when there is evidence of a crime.
Recent events show that if the U.S. government fails to enforce its own laws, foreign courts may step into the breach.
One effort to hold U.S. officials accountable in a foreign court is already underway. Last Friday, Judge Baltasar Garzón (left) of the Spanish National Court decided that a criminal complaint against six Bush administration lawyers and advisers could proceed. The complaint alleges that Spanish citizens detained at Guantánamo were subjected to a program of torture devised and authorized by senior Bush administration officials. (Prior IntLawGrrls posts here and here.) Although CJA supports the principle of universal jurisdiction underlying the Spanish criminal complaint, we strongly believe that the endgame must be a formal investigation of the allegations of torture and prosecutions in the U.S. justice system.
The timely release of the OLC torture memos and the Spanish criminal complaint underscore the urgent need for the U.S. government to take this essential step towards accountability.
Our human rights reputation depends on it.

Cheer the Beloved Country?

(My thanks to IntLawGrrls for the opportunity to contribute this guest-post)

Many people in South Africa cheered the announcement earlier this week by Mokotedi Mpshe (top right), acting Director of South Africa's National Prosecuting Authority, that the Authority had dismissed longstanding corruption charges against Jacob Zuma, the head of the African National Congress and the likely President of South Africa after elections on April 22. Amongst those cheering the announcement were ordinary South Africans, supporters of the ANC, trade union members, and members of South Africa's Communist Party. Perhaps even former President Thabo Mbeki cheered the part of Mpshe's announcement declaring the absence of evidence linking Mbeki to wrongdoing in the Authority's prosecution of Zuma (below right).
The cheering was not universal. The announcement was loudly protested by opposition parties such as the recently established Congress of the People, the Democratic Party, and their supporters, and many ordinary South Africans. They are left wondering what it all means for South Africa’s fledgling and fragile legal system.
Americans reading the news of Mpshe's action may initially think it is merely a parallel to the recent action of U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder dismissing charges against former U.S. Senator Ted Stevens. In both situations, the chief federal prosecutor in the nation dismissed
corruption charges against a high-ranking political official, and in both instances the court having jurisdiction over the case raised questions of prosecutorial abuse. In the Stevens case, the federal court even held prosecutors in contempt for withholding evidence, while in the Zuma case the court had gone so far as to dismiss the charges on the ground, subsequently overturned, that the then-President of South Africa had influenced the prosecution.
Notwithstanding the similarities, important differences exist between the two cases:
► First, Holder, a Democrat, was not a member of the same political party as Stevens, a Republican, and thus could not be suspected of acting out of party loyalty. This can't be said of Mpshe, who is a member of the ANC and a strong supporter of Zuma.
► Second, the justification cited by Holder for dismissing the prosecution -- namely, the withholding of potentially exculpatory evidence -- was a factor relevant to whether abuse of process had occurred and whether prosecution should continue. For reasons which will be apparent later, Mpshe's justification for discontinuance left the question of relevancy hanging.
It is important, however. to recognize that it would not be possible to assess the relevancy issue had Mpshe not made available for public review the contents of the surreptitiously recorded telephone conversations upon which he based dismissal of the charge. This was an important step, and Mpshe performed a great service for the nation in taking it. The secretly taped conversations were between the former head of the National Prosecuting Authority and the chief of Scorpions, the nation's chief police force. Mpshe promised an investigation of the secret recordings of these conversations. But having verified their authenticity, he took full account of them, had them declassified, and released them for public review. He should be commended for this, and for the terms of the announcement respecting the dismissal of the Zuma charges. They include, as previously stated, clearing Mbeki of any wrongdoing, disclosing the existence of disagreement amongst his staff about the dismissal, and informing the public of the criterion he applied in determining if the charges should be dismissed. That criterion, he said, was whether prosecutors had abused the legal process.
These actions of Mpshe are good for South Africa because transparency in governmental affairs is critical for the functioning of the country's democracy.
Where Mpshe's actions fell short was in the application of his criterion for determining whether to dismiss the charges. The failure was two-fold:
► First, the tapes appear principally to show only that political considerations were interjected into the timing of the prosecution against Zuma, yet to show nothing in connection with the prosecution itself.
► Second, Mpshe didn't specify which parts of the taped conversations he regarded as evidence of an abuse of process sufficient to warrant dismissal of the charges.
From this, the only conclusion to be drawn is that for Mpshe, the mixing of political considerations with the timing of the commencement of the lawsuit constituted by itself sufficient infection of the judicial process to warrant dismissal of corruption charges against Zuma. Since there was no allegation the timing of the lawsuit had anything to do with the course, or outcome, of the trial, this is a rather surprising conclusion, and one providing little guidance to other prosecutors.
The next step is for a South African court to decide whether to accept the dismissal. However, the court may simply defer to the discretion of the prosecutor, leaving unsettled the issue of how the criterion of abuse of process should be applied in such dismissals.
What I think we can all cheer at this point is the enormous importance of the transparency Mpshe has brought to this issue, a transparency which also allows for accountability of Mpshe's action. On the other hand, Mpshe has set a precedent which may afford too much leeway for injecting politics into decisions of prosecutors on whether to dismiss criminal charges.
In some ways this decision stands as a gauge of the state of fifteen years of South African constitutional democracy; that is, there is much to commend it, but some misgiving persist.

 
Bloggers Team