Showing posts with label Jennifer Kreder. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jennifer Kreder. Show all posts

Go On! Human rights & cultural heritage

(Delighted to welcome back alumna Jennifer Kreder, who contributes this Go On! guest post)

With the political turmoil in the Middle East and recent devastating earthquakes in Haiti, Chile, and Turkey, the timing is – unfortunately – excellent for Human Rights and Cultural Heritage: From the Holocaust to the Haitian Earthquake, a conference to be held March 31, 2011, at Benjamin Cardozo School of Law, 55 Fifth Avenue, New York City.
Cohosting in addition to Cardozo's Art Law Society are the Cultural Heritage and the Arts Interest Group of the American Society of International Law (an interest group for which I serve as co-chair), the Lawyers' Committee for Cultural Heritage Preservation, and the Hofstra Law School Art and Cultural Heritage Club. Generously supporting the conference are the Commission for Art Recovery and the New York law firm Herrick Feinstein, LLP.
The daylong conference will include an impressive group of diverse perspectives – including a keynote address by Howard N. Spiegler, partner and co-chair of Herrick Feinstein's Art Law Group – and will cover a broad range of topics relating to the intersection of human rights and cultural heritage across the globe.
The schedule of speakers and topics is available here. Space is limited, so be sure to register soon!


In passing: Maria Altmann

Maria Altmann (right), who won her Supreme Court case seeking recovery of art stolen from her family during the Nazi era, died Monday at her home.
She'd been born Maria Viktoria Bloch-Bauer 94 years earlier, the youngest child in a wealthy Viennese family. The family included her maternal aunt Adele, who sat for the 1907 portrait at right, by Gustav Klimt. (credit for 2006 photo by Tom Tugend)
Having fled Nazi-occupied Vienna as a newlywed, Altmann did not learn of the whereabouts of this and other items in her family's art collection until 1999. By then she was an 82-year-old widowed grandmother living in Los Angeles County.
She filed a claim that went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. In Republic of Austria v. Altmann (2004), Justices ruled 8-1 in her favor and, as described in a post by IntLawGrrls guest/alumna Jennifer Kreder, the portrait and other paintings were returned to her.

Go On! Preserving culture

(Go On! is an occasional item on symposia and other events of interest)

International Historic Preservation in Context with the National Historic Preservation Act is the topic of a conference to be held 4-8 p.m. this Thursday, October 14, at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 1779 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W., in Washington, D.C. Cosponsors include the Cultural Heritage & the Arts Interest Group of the American Society of International Law -- a group for which IntLawGrrls guest/alumna Jennifer Kreder serves as a co-chair. Continuing Legal Education credits will be available; program details and registration here.

Nazi-looted art & California

(Delighted to welcome back IntLawGrrl alumna Jennifer Kreder, who contributes this On Art! guest post)

Latest developments in California respecting claims for recovery of artworks stolen by the Nazis in World War II: legislation that would ease the ligitation of looted-art-recovery claims awaits decision by California governor, and an en banc panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has issued an interlocutory ruling in favor of one such claim.

Pending legislation
Some history is in order to understand the significance of A.B. 2765, the bill that California legislators approved at the end of last month.
► In 2009, in von Saher v. Norton Simon Museum of Art at Pasadena, a 3-member panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit struck down § 354.3 of the California Code of Civil Procedure. That law had attempted to extend, to December 31, 2010, the statute of limitations applicable to claims seeking restitution of Nazi-looted art against museums and galleries. But the Ninth Circuit held that the state statute was preempted under the foreign affairs doctrine.
The von Saher case involves Adam and Eve (right), a circa-1530 diptych painted by Lucas Cranach the Elder, which had undeniably been stolen from one of the most prominent art dealers in Europe, Jacques Goudstikker, whose Amsterdam gallery was aryanized after he fled for his life (and who died in an accident on the fleeing ship). The Dutch government seems to have mistakenly returned the paintings to the wrong family after the war, and the paintings were later sold by an art dealer to the museum. Under the American common law of property, an axiomatic rule is that title to stolen art does not pass except in limited circumstances involving bailments – although limitations periods could bar a claim.
A petition for certiorari is set to be considered by the U.S. Supreme Court at its conference on September 27.
► In 2007, another 3-member panel of the Ninth Circuit, in Orkin v. Taylor, had ruled both that federal law created no private right of action for Holocaust survivors and heirs to seek restitution of their art, and that the California conversion/replevin cause of action accrues when the “plaintiff discovers or reasonably could have discovered her claim to and the whereabouts of her property.” (credit for photo of Vincent Van Gogh painting in dispute in Orkin)
A number of courts across the country recently have been interpreting constructive notice standards in ways that do not account for the inability of Holocaust survivors and their heirs to truly discover until now their ability to reclaim artwork stolen or sold under duress or in a forced sale.
The Supreme Court declined the petition for certiorari filed in this case.
The California legislation that is awaiting signature or veto by Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger would:
► Require actual notice; and
► Double the length of time allowed between actual discovery and commencement of the cause of action, from three to six years.
The law would apply to all new and pending causes of action commenced on or before December 31, 2017. It also would include actions that were dismissed based on the expiration of the statute of limitations in effect prior to the date of enactment. Although the new standard would apply only to art in museums and galleries in California, it could pave the way for more state-level reform.

New ruling
While this statewide legislation was pending, an en banc panel of the San Francisco-based federal appellate court issued a ruling that permitted another recovery suit to go forward.
In Cassirer v. Kingdom of Spain, decided in mid-August, the en banc Ninth Circuit panel held 9-2 that Spain and its instrumentality, the Madrid-based Thyssen-Bornemisza Collection Foundation, are subject to U.S. jurisdiction under the expropriation exception of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act – even though it was the Nazis, not Spain, that engaged in the expropriation.
The court in Cassirer held that the plain language of 28 U.S.C. § 1605(a)(3), which states only that the property be “taken in violation of international law,” has no requirement as to who must actually engage in the taking. The court then found that the Foundation is engaged in sufficient commercial activity in the United States – advertising for tourism – to fall under the commercial activity exception in this section of the FSIA.
In light of the limited jurisdiction it possessed on interlocutory appeal, the Ninth Circuit in Cassirer declined to engage in an extensive review of defense arguments that the plaintiff was required to exhaust local remedies for jurisdiction to lie in the United States. It also declined to review the lower court’s denial of the motion to dismiss on grounds related to personal jurisdiction and the case-or-controversy requirement.
The plaintiff, Southern California resident Claude Cassirer, seeks recovery of Rue Saint-Honoré, après-midi, effet de pluie (below right). A Nazi agent allegedly (and in this author’s opinion certainly) confiscated this 1897 painting by the impressionist Camille Pissaro from the plaintiff’s grandmother, Lily Cassirer. (image credit) The Ninth Circuit in Cassirer reiterated the basic allegations as follows:

In 1939 Lilly decided she had no choice but to leave Germany. By that time – as the district court judicially noticed – German Jews had been deprived of their civil rights, including their German citizenship; their property was being “Aryanized”; and the Kristallnacht pogroms had taken place throughout the country. Permission was required both to leave and to take belongings. The Nazi government appointed Munich art dealer Jakob Scheidwimmer as the official appraiser to evaluate the works of art, including the Pissarro painting, that Lilly wished to take with her. Scheidwimmer refused to allow her to take the painting out of Germany and demanded that she hand it over to him for approximately $360. Fearing she would not otherwise be allowed to go, and knowing she would not actually get the money because the funds would be paid into a blocked account, Lilly complied.

The court explained how the painting made its way to the collection of the Thyssen-Bornemisza Collection Foundation:

Schweidwimmer traded the painting to another art dealer, who was also persecuted and fled Germany for Holland. After Germany invaded Holland, the Gestapo confiscated the painting and returned it to Germany, where it was sold at auction to an anonymous purchaser in 1943. It turned up at a New York gallery in 1952 and was sold to a St. Louis collector; it was sold again in 1976 to a New York art dealer who, in turn, sold it to Baron Hans-Heinrich Thyssen-Bornemisza. Bornemisza lived in Switzerland and was a preeminent private collector.

A petition for certiorari almost certainly will be filed with the Supreme Court.

Open wounds after war

(Delighted to welcome back alumna Jennifer Kreder, who contributes this guest post)

The first major Khmer Rouge defendant has been brought to justice with the 30-year sentence just handed down (left), as posted, by the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia. (photo credit)
I believe postwar prosecutions for human rights violations are beneficial for victims, but that there are risks as well. When people who have committed heinous crimes get less than the maximum sentence, I think it is foreseeable that many victims will be hurt again. On the other hand, if every defendant gets the maximum sentence, the tribunal will not appear to be objective.
Then, there are other ways to deal with postwar open wounds, such as truth commissions and civil litigation, which may occur in courts beyond the borders of the nation that experienced war (often internal civil war).
I would love to hear others' viewpoints about these issues:
► What do you think is helpful for the individual victims and the nation, and why?
► Should U.S. courts hear postwar claims? If so, when and why?
► Should it depend on the location of victims who fled a murderous regime? Or on the location of their property? Or on whether significant remedies are available in the nation where the war occurred?
► Should it depend on a green light from the executive branch?
I am currently exploring the intersection of the "open wounds" idea and the cultural property arena.
For example, Tuol Sleng (right), the prison where the just-sentenced defendant, known as Duch, led the torture and murder of so many innocents, is now a Genocide Museum.
Part of Tuol Sleng's roof collapsed last week. Some people said the souls of the dead were crying out for justice.
Certain types of property, real property and chattels, have meaning that transcends finances. Caring for such property thoughtfully can help heal postwar wounds, whereas its destruction can feel like new wounds to wartime victims.
Another example of the intersection of human rights, war, and cultural property concerns terrorism and antiquities that were found within the borders of modern-day Iran but now are located in U.S. museums.
In recent years Congress a number of laws purporting to give victims of terrorism means to redress:
► That part of the 1996 Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act that allows American victims to sue countries designated as sponsors of terrorism; and
► The Civil Liability for Acts of State Sponsored Terrorism Act, a/k/a the Flatow Amendment in honor of victim Alisa Flatow), which authorizes U.S. courts to award money damages to victims of terrorism.
In fact, this legislation has proved ineffectual -- a “sound bite” that has foisted conflicting jurisdictional mandates upon the federal courts, sucked terrorist victims into a vacuous, exhausting drama with no chance for justice, and interfered with the President’s ability to conduct diplomatic relations in the Middle East.
One group of victims is mired in multiple jurisdictions, trying to enforce an extremely large default judgment against the Islamic Republic of Iran by forcing auctions of antiquities like these Persian tablets, housed at the University of Chicago's Oriental Institute. Other collections subject to this complex litigation may be found at, to name a few sites, Harvard University, the Field Museum of Natural History in Chicago, and the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston. Congress, in this political posturing, required the U.S. Department of Justice to participate in the litigation in a way that runs counter to the victims’ interest. The victims likely feel ignored and maligned by their own President, while Congress all along was the master puppeteer of their false hopes. Kimberly deGraaf and I have co-authored an article on the subject, "Museums in the Crosshairs: Unintended Consequences of the War on Terror," forthcoming in the Duke Journal of Comparative & International Law.
No one believes that dealing with property ever will bring back the dead or afford full "justice" to victims. But many of us believe that the symbolism of such property is significant.
Do you have thoughts on these issues?
Can you provide other examples of postwar wounds that need redress to allow healing to occur?


(A version of this post appears at PrawsfBlog)

On Art! History & Holocaust claims

(Today alumna Jennifer Kreder contributes another On Art! guest post, prompted by her work in a pending looted-art case; her prior, related posts are here and here)

What judges think of their function and task undoubtedly informs their understanding of their power or jurisdiction.
In a March 3d order denying reconsideration of her January 6th dismissal of the heirs' lawsuit in the Nazi-looted-art case of Grosz v. MoMA, U.S. District Court Judge Colleen McMahon (below right) of the Southern District of New York stated on page 11 that the court was confronted
with a legal, not a historical, question.
This view is a false dichotomizing of the judicial function.
Judges cannot be expected to know intimately the historical context of all cases that come before them. But under precedents like Iqbal, Twombly and their progeny, judges should not ignore widely accepted historical facts when deciding whether a claim arguing that a seemingly voluntary transaction was, in fact, made under duress is “plausible.”
From the very beginning of the Nazi era, law and jurisprudence became a strong component of justification of regulations that deprived “enemies of the State” of their liberty and property, and these deprivations led in turn to mass murder.
Indeed, as documented in Robbing the Jews: The Confiscation of Jewish Property in the Holocaust, 1933-1945 (2008), by a Research Scholar at the Center for Advanced Holocaust Studies of the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum, Martin C. Dean, the “legalized” grand larceny became a form of financing the mass murder.
The Führerprinzip demanded unquestioning loyalty to the concentrated power of a “unitary executive.” Both legislators and judges in Nazi Germany participated in the normalization of practices of State grand theft that were engineered to make involuntary transactions appear “ordinary and legal” from the very first weeks of the Nazi regime early in 1933, even before the infamous racist Nuremberg laws of “blood and honor” in 1935, and even before the final push to a “Final Solution.” The U.S. Consul General in Vienna, immediately after the Anschluss of Austria in March 1938, poignantly observed:
There is a curious respect for legal formalities. The signature of the person despoiled is always obtained, even if the person in question has to be sent to Dachau in order to break down his resistance.
Jews were systematically excluded from professions and forced to compile inventories to streamline the despoliation of their property from 1933 to 1942, when Jews had little or no property left to rob, and when the focus turned to “cost-efficient” mass murder in the death camps of occupied Poland.
It is a gross distortion of reality to suggest that the financial despair of Jews in 1933, during widespread, sporadic boycotts and until the passage of the first Nuremberg law in 1935, resulted from a series of isolated private setbacks brought about by generalized, severe financial conditions akin to the Great Depression. The National Socialist platform, adopted as official German state policy as of 1933, was committed to driving Jews and other “enemies of the State” out of economic life.
This is the historical context in which modern claims to Nazi-looted art should be viewed.
Too frequently, some of our judges seem to have forgotten history. In kneejerk fashion, some seem to assume that claims 70 years old simply cannot be viable. This reaction is contrary to history, and to the U.S. executive policy. Consider, in addition to documents on which I earlier posted, this August 27, 1951, statement, "The Recovery of Cultural Objects Dispersed during World War II," by Ardelia R. Hall, the Fine Arts & Monuments Adviser to the U.S. State Department, which appeared in the Department's Bulletin:
For the first time in history, restitution may be expected to continue for as long as works of art known to have been plundered during a war continue to be rediscovered.
The executive branch has not deviated from this position to date.

(A version of this post appears at PrawsfBlog)

Cultural property postcard from Italy

(Delighted to welcome back alumna Jennifer Kreder, who contributes another this guest post)

AMELIA, Umbria, Italy -- The field of cultural property is not just about restitution. It’s also about preservation of monuments, objects, heritage and the archaeological record, among other things. When objects are clandestinely ripped from the ground for the black market, their contexts are destroyed, and we lose historical data from which we would know so much more about beautiful objects.
I’m currently writing during a sleepless, hot night in this beautiful town outside of Rome, a place with a rich history.
The region, Umbria, is a place of incredible archaeological richness. (credit for photo at left of Roman Theatre at Spoleto in Umbria)
At the top of this hill city, Amelia (above right), is featured a tower outside the beautiful Catholic church; it utilizes Roman and pre-Roman archeological materials. (photo credit)
When I was still in Rome, I managed to squeeze in time at the Roman Forum, Palatine, Borghese Galleries (and surrounds) and at the Piazza Navona (for tartufo, the ice cream dessert below right).
But, I must return to my husband and four-year-old son. My son believes part of my mission to Italy was to determine which Transformers (below left) Italian kids like. The outcome of this anthropological study remarkably coincides with the secret Transformer stash in our basement.
Anyway . . .
By 1909, Italy passed its first “in-the-ground” statute, which vested ownership of all unearthed antiquities in the state. Greek vases have nonetheless, since then, been dug out of Roman soil by the truckloads. They have trafficked through “reputable” dealers into some of the most esteemed museums in the world. A few of our most esteemed institutions that have returned loot, among them The Getty in Southern California, the Cleveland Museum of Art, and the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. Over 100 objects have been returned from U.S. museums and collectors in the last three years or so, largely as a result of Polaroids found in a raid on a Swiss warehouse in a Geneva airport, as documented in The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of Looted Antiquities--From Italy's Tomb Raiders to the World's Greatest Museums, a 2006 book by Peter Watson and Cecelia Todeschini. Some of those antiquities are now on display in Rome, including in the National Etruscan Museum in the Villa Giulia.
The 2010 Conference on the Study of Art Crime was the occasion for my trip to Italy. It was hosted by ARCA, the Association for Research into Crimes against Art, a think tank which runs the first master's program in the interdisciplinary field of art theft.
Conference presentations, which will be posted on-line in the near future, covered a diverse array of fields, including:
► Museum security,
► Cultural identity,
► Archaeology,
► The relationship of looting and terrorist funding, and
► Nazi-looted art.
I particularly enjoyed hearing from Giovanni Pastore, former Vice-Commandant of the Carabinieri Division for the Protection of Cultural Heritage and an ARCA trustee. Part of his presentation was broadcast on Italian television.
* * *
Do you love antiquity? History? Beautiful objects? Culture? Heritage? Art – old or new? If so, I hope you’ll consider joining the American Society of International Law Interest Group on Cultural Heritage and the Arts (prior post), for which I serve as co-chair, or contributing to our Cultural Heritage & the Arts Review (prior post), which our interest group publishes.
Our field is highly polarized. Very few of us agree with each other on all issues, but most of us are open to a good debate and to introduction of new views. The field consists of a small number of lawyers, but a much larger community of people involved in archaeology, site preservation, government, museums, collecting, auction houses, military, indigenous groups and other organizations, and there is room for more -- more profs, law students, and others! Join us to learn about the law surrounding cultural property and heritage!

(A version of this post appeared at PrawfsBlawg)

On Art! U.S. executive policy on looted art

(Today alumna Jennifer Kreder contributes another On Art! guest post, prompted by her work in a pending looted-art case; her 1st, related post is here)

The Executive Branch of the United States long has carried out a consistent policy respecting art looted by Nazi Germany. This policy bears on the lawsuit in which heirs lay claim to certain paintings now in the George Grosz collection of the Museum of Modern Art in New York.
In January, a trial court dismissed the lawsuit as time-barred without reference to the complex historical factors delaying the heirs' assertion of their claims. In so doing, the court contravened foreign policy goals that the United States and the Allies pursued during and immediately after World War II and that a broad coalition of states pursued, via diplomatic breakthroughs, in 1998, 2000, and 2009. I detail the history in this post, which derives from the amicus brief that I co-authored in support of the heirs' pending appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2d Circuit in Manhattan (courthouse at right).
In the normal course of judicial administration touching on foreign policy, federal judges typically defer to determinations of policy matters by the executive branch.
One example of this rule unfolded in mid-20th C. litigation of Bernstein v. N. V. Nederlansche-Amerikaansche Stoomvaart-Maatschappij. In a 1949 decision in Bernstein, 173 F.2d 71, the 2d Circuit ruled inadmissible statements in which a Jewish victim of persecution described the brutal Nazi imprisonment that led him to “transfer” major assets under duress. To admit such evidence, the court reasoned, would denigrate a foreign country. Then, however, with regard to the same litigation, Jack B. Tate (below left), Acting Legal Adviser in the U.S. Department of State, wrote, as quoted here, of his

Government’s opposition to forcible acts of dispossession of a discriminatory and confiscatory nature practiced by the Germans on the countries or peoples subject to their controls . . . [and that] the policy of the Executive, with respect to claims asserted in the United States for restitution of such property, is to relieve American courts from any restraint upon the exercise of their jurisdiction to pass upon the validity of the acts of Nazi officials.
Having thus been informed of the government’s views of coerced “transactions” during the Nazi era in Germany, the 2d Circuit's 1954 judgment in Bernstein reversed its previous ruling in the same case.
This Tate letter was in no means the only exemplar of U.S. executive policy.
U.S. diplomats led efforts to warn other countries against looting in the landmark London Declaration of January 5, 1943, which

declare[d] invalid any [coerced] transfers of, or dealings with, property . . . whether such transfers or dealings have taken the form of open looting or plunder, or of transactions apparently legal in form, even when they purport to be voluntarily effected.

Immediately after the war, moreover, the International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg (right) -- convened by the United States along with Britain, France, and the Soviet Union -- had evaluated detailed evidence of coerced sales. (photo credit) The plunder of art was declared a war crime, and is so recognized today. At Nuremberg, it was perfectly clear to the factfinders who had done what and to whom. Thus the Tribunal convicted Alfred Rosenberg, head of the Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg art-looting unit, and sentenced him to death by hanging.
Shortly thereafter in Bonn and Vienna it was made clear in, for example, Military Government Law 59, that Germany and Austria had to repudiate all spurious “transactions” of the entire Nazi era, including art “deals” that were really seizures.
Thus, the model chosen was a restitution model for individual claims, and these claims were not subsumed in reparations paid after the war -- reparations that became limited as the United States implemented the Marshall Plan.
The amicus brief that I co-authored argues that the 2d Circuit must, as it did in its 1954 Bernstein ruling, accord to the Executive the deference described in the Tate letter.
Diplomats from the State Department, particularly Ambassador Stuart E. Eizenstat, played a leading role in securing multilateral public commitments, by scores of countries, to effective, fact-based resolution of Nazi-looted art claims. For example:
to develop national processes to implement these principles, particularly as they relate to alternative dispute resolution mechanisms for resolving ownership issues.
(credit for 1945 photo, republished during the 1999 Washington Conference, of U.S. soldier examining "paintings, part of the loot gathered from all parts of Europe by Hermann Goering, in 1945 in Germany")
► The 2009 Terezín Declaration similarly calls on countries to secure
just and fair solutions with regard to Nazi-confiscated and looted art, and to make certain that claims to recover such art are resolved expeditiously and based on the facts and merits of the claims and all the relevant documents submitted by all parties.
The Declaration further stresses that

Governments should consider all relevant issues when applying various legal provisions that may impede the restitution of art and cultural property, in order to achieve just and fair solutions, as well as alternative dispute resolution, where appropriate under law.
To give credit when due, this development in foreign policy was sparked in no small measure by Guidelines that the Association of American Museum Directors. Thus, it is quite shocking that some U.S. museums -- MoMA is one -- have interposed defenses like statute of limitations and laches. As demonstrated in this case-law chart that I've compiled, and as I've discussed further here, their efforts are all too often successful. This result thwarts the policy set forth above, distorting the historical record and law in the process.

(A version of this post appeared at PrawfsBlawg, where I'm guesting this month)

On Art! Grosz miscarriage of justice

(Delighted to welcome back alumna Jennifer Kreder, who contributes this On Art! guest post)

Pending in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit is Grosz v. The Museum of Modern Art, a challenge to the January dismissal-as-time-barred of a lawsuit brought in 2009 by heirs who claim that 3 George Grosz paintings in MoMA's extensive Grosz collection are illegally obtained Nazi loot. (Among the disputed works is the 1920 watercolor below right, entitled "Republican Automatons," and the 1928 painting below left, "Self-Portrait with Model") (image credits here and here)
I have co-authored an amicus brief, filed in the case last month, in which a number of Jewish community leaders, Holocaust educators, artists and art historians, and legal scholars and practitioners support the heirs' bid for reversal of the trial court's decision and reinstatement of the case.
Too many of us, unfortunately including a fair number of federal judges, seem to presume that claims to property taken long ago must be time-barred under some legal doctrine.
That presumption, however, is blocking our ability to bring sunlight to the dark, hidden history of the vastness of:
► Nazi looting,
► The art market’s greed in secretly snapping up bargains, and
► The fact that claimants often were unable to make claims in the postwar period.
Too many in the art community would have us believe that the fact that Nazis plundered more art than any other regime in history, surpassing even Napoleon, remained a mystery until academics and lawyers turned their attention to newly opened archives in the mid-1990s. This simply is not true, and it is directly relevant to whether purchasers acted in good faith and whether claimants could have identified their property claims and asserted them before now.
Diplomats from the U.S. State Department played a leading role in securing public commitment by the forty-four nations that adopted the Washington Conference Principles on Nazi-Confiscated Art in 1998 and the Terezín Declaration that emerged from the international conference hosted by the Czech Republic in June 2009. These instruments call for effective, fact-based resolution of Nazi-looted art claims – not for defeating them in court on statute of limitations grounds.
The brief that I filed along with my co-counsel, Valparaiso Law Professor Edward McGlynn Gaffney Jr., captures the current hostile climate for claims to Nazi-looted art. Museums are trampling the conciliatory and transparency touchstones in the Washington Principles, in the Terezin Declaration, and in their own guidelines. In so doing, they are convincing federal courts to accept distorted versions of historical fact going back to 1933, and to contravene consistent Executive Branch policies dating back to 1943.
Some American museums and others have managed to convince our federal courts that claims to Nazi-looted art are not worthy of treatment on the merits – grossly distorting the historical record in the process. Some courts seem to have been convinced that enemies of the Third Reich could all freely engage in voluntary property and business transactions up until the passage of the Nuremberg Laws, or even as late as 1938. Our brief uses irrefutable historical evidence to demonstrate the falsity of this position. The art world had contemporary knowledge of the massive infection of the art market with “flight art” starting in 1933.
In the Grosz case, the district court, in contradiction to Federal Rule of Evidence 408, took snippets of settlement discussions completely out of context, and so improperly ruled that MoMA's Director had refused the claim before, in fact, MoMA clearly did so. This ruling led to the conclusion that the plaintiff heirs had missed their court filing window by a few months. This flies in the face of the court’s express finding that the Director’s language was

almost certainly designed to entice plaintiffs to continue negotiating and to prevent the dispute from becoming public or escalating into litigation.

The district court’s ruling:
► Calls out for application of the equitable doctrines of tolling and estoppel;
► De-incentivizes good faith negotiation, while incentivizing museums to draw out negotiations in the hopes that plaintiffs will miss the limitations cutoff; and
► Guts Executive Branch policy since 1943.
Executive policy clearly acknowledges the length to which the Nazis went to mask aryanizations and forced sales of real and personal property as voluntary transactions and calls for their un-winding. Recent U.S.-led efforts, like the Washington and Terezín instruments described above, support resolution of Nazi-looted art claims via alternative dispute resolution methods that are premised on liberal access to provenance -- that is, ownership history -- records in order that the factual merits may be fully aired. Guidelines promulgated by the Association of American Museum Directors and the American Association of Museums mirror these standards.
MoMA has trampled over these declarations and guidelines.
MoMA refuses to disclose provenance records relevant to the Grosz case, much less to resolve the claim on the merits, despite 1998 testimony in which its Director told Congress that MoMA and the museum community support transparency, and despite MoMA’s website statement that its archives are open to all serious researchers.
As we argue in our brief, the district court seems to have prejudged the case at the motion-to-dismiss stage, by:
► Characterizing evidence about the tainted history of the paintings at issue as “rank hearsay” despite logical inferences to be drawn from the true historical context;
► Endorsing MoMA’s protestations of confidentiality; and
► Inappropriately accepting MoMA's statute of limitations arguments mischaracterizing settlement communications.
The creator of the paintings at issue, Berlin-born Grosz, fled Germany for the United States in 1933, shortly before his 40th birthday. Later he was later declared an “enemy of the State” by the Nazi regime. Grosz left his art with a Jewish art dealer, who also later fled. The historical record documents that the dealer’s galleries were "aryanized." MoMA bought one of Grosz’ paintings in 1947, and another in 1954. (Grosz attained U.S. citizenship but eventually returned to Berlin, where he died in 1959.) Two "red flag" names identified as traffickers by the Art Looting Investigation Unit of the U.S. Office of Strategic Services, which would be familiar to any provenance researcher, appear in the provenances of the paintings at issue. Not caring does not equate to not knowing.
Unfortunately, this case is not unusual.

(A version of this post appeared at PrawfsBlawg, where I'm guesting this month)

Review of Cultural Heritage

(IntLawGrrls is pleased to welcome back Jennifer Kreder, who contributes this guest post stemming from her work on issues related to cultural property)

The American Society of International Law Interest Group on Cultural Heritage & Arts, for which, as posted, I am a co-founder and serve as co-chair, has released the very first issue of the Cultural Heritage & Arts Review. In it you'll find a rich variety of articles, among them "High Seas Shipwreck Pits Treasure Hunters Against a Sovereign Nation: The Black Swan Case," by attorney Kimberly Alderman (right), "The UK’s Holocaust (Return of Cultural Objects) Act of 2009," by University of Derby Lecturer Charlotte Woodhead (left), "Should Cultural Heritage Be on the Judicial Auction Block?" by attorney Laina Lopez (below right), a Co-Vice Chair of our Interest Group, and "Heritage Watch Acts to Protect Cambodian Cultural Heritage," by Terressa Davis, an Executive Consultant to the Association for Research into Crimes against Art and a Review editor.
To access these and the many other articles in this 1st edition, click here to open the Review in Acrobat Reader, go to the Table of Contents page, click on "View" in the toolbar, then "Navigation Panels" in the 1st popup box, "Bookmarks" in the 2d.
A limited high-quality print edition will be available soon. Please contact yours truly at krederj1@nku.edu if you'd like to place an order.
Our Interest Group's March panel discussion on Cultural Heritage and the Arts Interest Group: Wrestling the Dead Hand of History: Perspectives on a Proposed State Department Commission on Nazi Looted Art, which I previewed in an earlier post, was a great success (as I detail in another Review article). If you missed it, it's available on tape by searching for the panel title here.
We are recruiting for editors and writers for the Review's next issue, to be published in the Fall. Please contact me if you're interested in contributing.
To join ASIL and our new Interest Group, click here.

Guest Blogger: Jennifer Kreder

It's IntLawGrrls' great pleasure to welcome Jennifer Kreder (right) as today's guest blogger.
Associate Dean for Faculty Development and Associate Professor of Law at Northern Kentucky University's Salmon P. Chase College of Law, Jennifer's an expert on laws respecting art and cultural property. She's the author of a chapter in the 2009 Yearbook of Cultural Property Law, and has presented both in the United States and abroad. In her guest post below, Jennifer discusses a few of her recent publications on Nazi-confiscated art, and further discusses the American Society of International Law Interest Group on Cultural Heritage & the Arts that she's just cofounded. As she described, the group has organized a panel Friday at the annual meeting of ASIL. (Prior IntLawGrrls posts on this week's meeting are here and here.)
Before entering academia, Jennifer was a Litigation Associate with Milbank, Tweed, Hadley & McCloy LLP in New York, concentrating on Holocaust era intergovernmental negotiation and litigation issues, art disputes, and class actions. In 2009 she took part in a State Department meeting to prepare for the Diplomatic Conference on Holocaust Era Assets held later that year in Prague, and also coauthored motion and amicus brief concerning conflicts law and Holocaust history in a critical Nazi-looted art appeal. She previously served as Co-Chair of the Art & Cultural Heritage Committee of the American Bar Association Section of International Law, and is active in the Lawyers Committee for Cultural Heritage Protection.
Jennifer earned her J.D. from Georgetown University Law Center, and her B.A. in political science, with high honors, from the University of Florida, and studied at Karl Marx University of Leipzig, Germany, as well as in Austria, Costa Rica and Mexico. She clerked for U.S. District Judge Barefoot Sanders, Northern District of Texas, and has taught at Stetson University College of Law, including in its study abroad program in Estonia, and in the Gonzaga University School of Law Florence, Italy program.
Heartfelt welcome!

International law, cultural heritage & the arts: Subject of new ASIL Interest Group

(My thanks to IntLawGrrls for the opportunity to contribute this guest post regarding my research and the Interest Group on Cultural Heritage & the Arts, which I'm helping to launch at the American Society of International Law Annual Meeting this week, about which IntLawGrrls already have posted here and here)

Most people don’t realize that one core component of the Nazis’ Final Solution was to steal Jews’ art collections and eliminate from the Reich modern art, which they deemed a degenerate influence on Germanic culture. The Nazis stole more art than any regime in history – even more than Napoleon. It is widely accepted that over 100,000 significant art objects stolen in the Holocaust era remain unaccounted for. Some were destroyed, but the prewar-art market is infected with Nazi-looted art.
The Western world tried to reach some agreement on how to deal with the issue in 1998, when forty-four nations signed onto the Washington Conference Principles on Nazi-Confiscated Art. These Principles called for:
► increased research on provenance, or ownership history;
► creation of alternative dispute mechanisms; and
► reaching of “just and fair” solutions.
The Principles recognized that what is “just and fair” may differ from case to case. National laws differ significantly in terms of whether a modern claimant to such art could successfully sue. Historically, U.S. law has been regarded as the most favorable toward claimants. The landmark Supreme Court judgment in Republic of Austria v. Altmann (2004) favored the claimant and resulted in the transfer of the painting above right, by Gustav Klimt, from a Vienna museum to a descendant of the woman depicted in the portrait. Since then, however, a wave of cases has significantly shifted the legal landscape in U.S. courts.
Ambassador Stuart E. Eizenstat, who had headed the U.S. delegation to the Washington Conference, was appointed to head the U.S. delegation to the June 2009 Holocaust Era Assets Conference in Prague, Czech Republic. The Assets Conference resulted in the Terezin Declaration, which reaffirmed support for the Washington Principles. But the Terezin Declaration specifically mentions “forced sales” as opposed to just “confiscated art.” What exactly is a “forced sale” is a raging debate in the art world.
A current wave of claims attempts to expand the definition of “forced sale” to include all property sold as a consequence of the Nazis’ rise to power in 1933. If courts hearing pending claims adopt such a definition, the number of art objects potentially subject to restitution could be astronomical – but is the definition right? Out of fear, U.S. museums have begun filing declaratory judgment actions raising technical defenses to defeat such claims.
The Department of State’s Special Envoy for Holocaust Issues, Ambassador J. Christian Kennedy, has hosted a series of town hall meetings since 2009 to explore the idea of creating a national commission to issue nonbinding opinions regarding claims to art displaced during the Holocaust.
My most recent article, The New Battleground of Museum Ethics and Holocaust Era Claims: Technicalities Trumping Justice or Responsible Stewardship for the Public Trust?, explores these developments. In true academic fashion, although I am in favor of a commission, I posit that national legislation would be best to deal with the problem in a binding fashion. In fact, also in true academic fashion, two of my earlier articles (here and here) propose creating an unpopular international tribunal.
To foster further exploration of these issues, Cristian DeFrancia and I recently cofounded a new American Society of International Law Interest Group on the International Law of Cultural Heritage & the Arts. Its first panel will be held this Friday, March 26, from 2:30 to 4 p.m. at the ASIL Annual Meeting at the Ritz-Carlton in Washington. The panel is entitled "Wrestling the Dead Hand of History: Perspectives on a Proposed State Department Commission on Nazi Looted Art," and features Ambassadors Kennedy and Eizenstat, Dr. Lucille A. Roussin (left) of Cardozo School of Law, and New York-based attorney Charles A. Goldstein. I will serve as moderator.
Details on the annual meeting -- including onsite registration -- are here.
Additionally, the Interest Group is seeking 500-2,500-word submissions, on any topic in art and cultural heritage law, for its newsletter. E-mail me at krederj1@nku.edu if you wish to become involved with this new ASIL Interest Group.

 
Bloggers Team