Showing posts with label disability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label disability. Show all posts

Go On! ASIL International Disability Rights Interest Group

This post is adapted from a call for membership circulated by Stephanie Ortoleva and Hope Lewis.
This exciting new group joins numerous other long-standing ASIL interest groups and will be co-chaired in this inaugural phase by Stephanie Ortoleva, Senior Human Rights Legal Advisor, BlueLaw International, LLP, and Visiting Scholar, University of Hawaii, Spring 2011-12 (photo) and IntLawGrrl Hope Lewis, Professor of Law, Northeastern University School of Law. Founding Executive Committee members are Janet E. Lord, Senior Partner, BlueLaw, LLP and Michael Waterstone, Associate Dean for Research and Academic Centers, Loyola Law School of Los Angeles.
The IDRIG will have its first strategy and planning meeting at the 105th ASIL Annual Meeting on Friday, March 25, from 9 to 10:30 a.m. in the Roosevelt Room, Ritz Carlton Hotel, Georgetown, Washington, DC, 1150 22nd Street, N.W.
We encourage you to join us as we plan our strategy and activities for the forthcoming year. Even if you cannot attend this first meeting, please join the interest group so you can be part of our exciting work.
More information on the International Disability Rights Interest Group is available here.
IDRIG's Mission
The interest group's mission is described as follows:

The American Society of International Law International Disability Rights Interest Group (IDRIG) focuses on disability rights as this issue moves from the margins of international human rights law and policy to occupy a prominent place in the global human rights system with the adoption of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD). The CRPD is moving in the direction of universal signature and already has nearly 100 ratifications, signaling the importance of the treaty to more than 650 million persons with disabilities worldwide. The CRPD has prompted an unprecedented pace of law reform worldwide and the establishment of an Inter-Agency mechanism to ensure disability inclusion across the United Nations system. It is also markedly shaping the human rights agendas of mainstream human rights organizations as well as international development agencies. The IDRIG works to promote awareness of disability rights as a cross-cutting issue in international law, sponsoring panels and other events at ASIL. Through an online discussion forum, DRIG provides information on recent developments in the field, an opportunity for networking among the rapidly growing numbers of international disability rights academics, practitioners, and advocates, discussing issues and recent developments in the field, sharing and collaborating on research, and furthering the inclusion of persons with disabilities in the work of ASIL. IDRIG also supports, encourages, and provides leadership opportunities to law students and emerging young lawyers in the growing field. Finally, and crucially, IDRIG advances the diversity of ASIL membership and facilitates the accessibility of ASIL to international lawyers with disabilities.


As you can tell, we have much work to do! If you are not already an ASIL member, information on joining ASIL can be found here.
Contact Stephanie Ortoleva or Hope Lewis with any questions. We look forward to meeting you on the 25th!

Enabling Asylum Seekers with Disabilities

Mindful of Hope Lewis's exhortation to include disability rights in human rights analyses, and in honor of the International Day of Persons with Disabilities, my post today reviews a recent study of asylum seekers with disabilities in Europe. This UNHCR research paper, written by Clara Straimer (pictured below right) and entitled Vulnerable or invisible? Asylum seekers with disabilities in Europe, echoes Hope's call to ensure that the disabled are included in the ostensibly universal scope of human rights obligations. Focusing on the Common European Asylum System but applicable to asylum determination processes worldwide, the paper seeks to "render visible the relevance of disability in the context of asylum."
Straimer's study begins and ends with the point the suffering of disabled asylum seekers is largely overlooked. The UN Refugee Convention provides no guidance on accommodating the needs of disabled asylum applicants, nor has the UN High Commissioner for Refugees promulgated any guidelines on a disability-sensitive interpretation of refugee law. Such an interpretation should view disability as structural oppression rather than an abnormality; in Straimer's words, as "disabling barriers imposed on persons with impairments by an exclusionary society." This social and human rights based approach to disability is exemplified by the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD), which focuses on recognizing the equality and capabilities of persons with disabilities and providing reasonable accommodation for disability-specific needs. It is surprising and concerning that UNHCR has yet to engage with the UNCRPD.
This legal lacuna belies the fact that disability may present a significant barrier to protection and can provoke and result from displacement. Disability may create multiple barriers to accessing asylum processes -- when combined with obstacles of language and citizenship, asylum seekers with disabilities may be prevented from even presenting their asylum claims. Even those asylum seekers with disabilities who access the process may face particular impediments to obtaining protection. For example, mental impairments may interact with the credibility determination process in a way that excludes the disabled from gaining asylum status. Moreover, asylum seekers with disabilities may have specific health care and accommodation needs that may go unnoticed during and after the asylum process. Finally, asylum law is insufficient in its recognition that disability may be a cause of displacement though discrimination, stigmatization, harassment, and neglect of persons with disabilities in their own communities is widespread.
Straimer walks the reader through the European Union's law and policy on disability and finds that they are in line with the UNCRPD's holistic understanding of disability. However, in practice, member states discriminate in the application of disability rights to nationals and non-nationals both at border and within borders. Moreover, Straimer's examination of the European asylum process directives highlights the need to ensure an individual assessment rather than a group-based understanding of disability. The study notes that while the Receptions Conditions Directive does a good job meeting this standard, the Asylum Procedures Directive and Qualification Directive do not. The former fails to recognize the diversity of disability (intellectual, physical) and the resultant principle that asylum seekers with disabilities don't need "special" treatment in all contexts. The latter fails to recognize disability as a particular social group. Both of these failures render barriers to asylum for the disabled invisible, in stark contrast to the visibility of gender and minority barriers to asylum.
Straimer then describes the qualitative research she performed to determine the reasons for this invisibility. The results and analysis are well worth reading further; I won't, however, describe these here in hope that the reader will be enticed into reading this ground-breaking study!

You Go, 'Grrl

On this International Day of Persons with Disabilities, we are proud to congratulate IntLawGrrl Hope Lewis, who is featured in the December 2010 American Bar Association Lawyer Spotlight. In Hope's words, "Even before I had a disability, I saw disability as a human rights issue." She also discusses the global dimensions of disability discrimination and the importance of ensuring that members of society are proactive in their approach to disability rights. Hope provides human rights lawyers and scholars with an important reminder:
When considering human rights, disability rights must be included if "human rights" are to be holistic concepts.

Prizing human rights

An institution established in memory of a Nuremberg prosecutor is seeking prize nominees.
Institution:
The Thomas J. Dodd Research Center, dedicated in 1995 at the University of Connecticut. The Center's namesake is Thomas J. Dodd, who began his career in the U.S. Department of Justice and went on to serve as a senior prosecutor at Nuremberg (right), cross-examining defendants in the Trial of the Major War Criminals and serving too in subsequent Nuremberg proceedings. (photo credit) Dodd, born in 1907, was a Democratic U.S. Senator from Connecticut from 1959 until a few months before his death in 1971; his children include the retiring senior Senator from Connecticut, who published his father's Letters from Nuremberg (2007), as well as a former U.S. Ambassador.
Prize:
The Thomas J. Dodd Prize in International Justice and Human Rights, awarded biennially by the University of Connecticut "to an individual or group who has made a significant effort to advance the cause of international justice and global human rights." Previous winners (here and here): 2003, Bertie Ahern and Tony Blair, then Prime Ministers of Ireland and Britain, respectively; 2005, Louise Arbour (left), then U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights, and former South African Constitutional Court Justice Richard J. Goldstone, like Arbour a onetime Chief Prosecutor of the International Criminal Tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda; 2007, the Center for Justice & Accountability, of which IntLawGrrls guest/alumna Pamela Merchant serves as Executive Director, and Mental Disability Rights International, last month renamed Disability Rights International; and 2009, the Committee to Protect Journalists.
To nominate a worthy individual or group for this monetary prize (no self-nominations accepted), complete and submit the form available here. Deadline is December 31, 2010.

Read On! The Vagrants

(Read On! ... occasional posts on writing we're reading)

To tell the same story from different viewpoints is not new. The technique won renown in the film Rashômon (1950), and has remained a staple of storytelling ever since.
Yet the way that Yiyun Li (below right) deploys multiple narratives in The Vagrants (2009) is indeed something new.
This novel is the 1st by Li, who was born in Beijing, lived in China till 1996, and who's now an Assistant Professor of English at the University of California, Davis.
Li's novel revolves around a single event yet reveals a myriad of details about a time, a place, and a people.
The event is the execution of Gu Shan, an enemy of the state who years before had given her all to the Maoist vanguard. The time is 1979, the year Li turned 7; desires for democracy are stirring a decade after the Cultural Revolution. The place is Muddy River, a soulless, purpose-built factory city in a Chinese province far from the capital. The people are those who've come to inhabit this city -- vagrants all regardless of their station.
From among these vagrants, Li chooses her narrators. It is a rich assortment, richly characterized. Tiny Tong's tale of bewilderment is told alongside that of Kai, a broadcaster and mother who's married into the seeming safety of a leading political family, yet chafes at her role. Adolescent Nini's resentment at her very different restraints leads her to the loathsome arms of the amoral Bashi. The old Huas collect rubbish, and discarded daughters.
Li addresses an array of issues in The Vagrants: disability, poverty, criminal justice and capital punishment, education, familial hierarchy and filial duty. But she does so without polemic, through wonderfully written, intimate portraits of her characters. Each narrator's small story remains in mind even as the reader ponders Li's larger narrative of an empty and arbitrary society, in a state at odds with its people.
A literary jewel.

Foreign practice sheds light in Blind case

Was struck by something in this week's decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit in The American Council of the Blind v. Paulson (judgment available here).
It was not the court's 2-1 holding that, by refusing to design and issue paper money so that visually impaired persons can readily distinguish among denominations, the U.S. Treasury Department violated this statute:

No otherwise qualified individual with a disability in the United States ... shall, solely by reason of her or his disability, be excluded from the participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance or under any program or activity conducted by any Executive agency ....

Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, 29 U.S.C. § 794.
What was striking, rather, was that the court based its conclusion that Treasury had not made requisite accommodations on the fact that other countries had made such accommodations. "Of the 171 authorities issuing currency," Judge Judith W. Rogers wrote (p. 8), referring to a 1995 report, "only the United States prints bills that are identical in size and color in all denominations." She noted that Canada adopted accommodations in 1995 (above left), adding that such accommodations are part of the euro currency adopted in 2002 (below right). Judge A. Raymond Randolph dissented on the ground that the interlocutory decision was premature. His discussion also accepted foreign examples as relevant points of comparison -- as did media accounts of the decision (here and here).
The case seems a classic example of how consultation of foreign practice may aid interpretation of U.S. law -- the "comparable questions" example about which I've written here (pp. 1340-41) and here (pp. 605-06). Given objections to foreign consultation in other contexts, the fact that judicial use of a foreign yardstick in this case went unremarked is itself worthy of remark.

(Cross-posted at Slate's Convictions blog)

 
Bloggers Team