Showing posts with label brazil. Show all posts
Showing posts with label brazil. Show all posts

Recognizing Palestine

One nation in the Middle East is seeking a change in status even as a neighboring state faces a change in regime.
The nation is Palestine.
Though some members of the Palestinian people are dispersed, many live in the West Bank and Gaza, the latter of which shares a border with Egypt, locus of recent political ferment about which we've posted.* (map credit)
In these Palestinian territories, the entity known as the Palestinian Authority governs by dint of circa-1990s international agreement. The Authority administers "within the framework of a semi-presidential multi-party republic, with a Legislative Council, an executive President, and a Prime Minister leading the Cabinet."
IntLawyers will see in the above paragraph 3 of the 4 traditional indicia of statehood:
1) Permanent population;
2) Defined territory; and
3) Government.
Not immediately apparent is this indicator:
4) Capacity to enter into relations with other states.
The declaratory theory of statehood would emphasize the word "capacity" in that last phrase, so that statehood would exist whenever an entity possessing Nos. 1-3 has the ability to effect No. 4. Yet in practice the constitutive theory holds sway. For if no fully recognized states themselves recognize the entity -- if no states actually enter into relations with it -- the entity cannot act as a state.
Put another way:
Not everything that looks like a state and quacks like a state is able fully to operate as a state.
(image credit) The trickiness of that 4th indicator has left scholars chewing for years over Palestine's status.
► Even without sufficient recognition by others, does it sufficiently possess the 4 attributes?
► Is it a "state" for purposes, say, of litigating before the International Court of Justice, by ICJ Statute Article 34(1) a forum open only to "states"?
► For purposes of referring a situation to the International Criminal Court, as the Palestinian National Authority in fact is attempting to do?
► Does it benefit -- and it is burdened -- by other rights and duties of states?
Developments may be shifting this debate.
In recent months, a series of states has recognized Palestine as an equal sovereign.
December began with the announcement, on the 3d day of that month, that Brazil "recognized the state of Palestine along the 1967 borders before Israel's seizure of the West Bank." The notice in response to a Palestinian request, Politico's Laura Rozen reported, "took Washington by surprise." She added:
Brazil was the last of the so-called BRIC nations [Brazil, Russia, India, China] to recognize Palestine. More than 100 countries, including almost all the African and Arab ones, had recognized it, "so it was the natural thing to do," a Brazilian official explained ....
Days later, Argentina said it would recognize Palestine.
Less than a week into the New Year came news that Chile had recognized Palestine.
A couple weeks ago, Russia reaffirmed its recognition.
Then came Peru, reportedly joining Bolivia, Ecuador, Guyana, and Uruguay in addition to South American countries already named.
Last week, Suriname added its name to the list.
Such news has compelled France to deny reports that it too was ready to recognize.
Yet elsewhere in Europe, there are calls for recognition and, in the case of Ireland, a late January upgrading of the Irish presence in Palestine to a "diplomatic mission," a step short of recognition. (France, Spain, and Portugal already had made the same move.) Palestine continues to seek wider European recognition. The European Union-U.N.-Russia-U.S. "Quartet" was expected to discuss Palestine "on the sidelines" of a conference in Munich this past weekend.
What of the United States?
As of mid-January, the U.S. official word for such recognitions was "premature." Given that more than half the world's countries appear already to have recognized, it's a word that may be meant to imply a policy change sooner rather than later.


* Not-unrelated aside: CNN reports that in recent days, West Bank rallies in support of pro-democracy protests in Egypt have been "shut down by Palestinian Authority security claiming the participants did not have the appropriate permits to hold such events."

Now (en)force

The International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearances, (prior posts) has entered into force. (hat tip)
Some months after the U.N. General Assembly adopted the multilateral treaty on December 20, 2006, IntLawGrrl Jaya Ramji-Nogales predicted that this effort to address the phenomenon of forced disappearances "may represent the future of international human rights law – enforcement through specificity." Jaya wrote:
The enforced disappearance treaty makes the interesting move of labelling and targeting a certain pattern of human rights violations, thus creating very specific norms that might be used by advocates to overcome the enforcement problems faced by more general human rights treaties. In addition, the Convention’s enforcement committee has the ability to hear urgent claims, to undertake field investigations, and to bring widespread and systematic enforced disappearance to the attention of the General Assembly.
The treaty will be monitored, as Jaya's post indicated, by the U.N. Working Group on Enforced or Involuntary Disappearances. Among the 5 independent experts who comprise this Working Group is 1 woman, Jasminka Džumhur (left), a gender and human rights specialist from Bosnia and Herzegovina. Chairing the group is Jeremy J. Sarkin, a South African legal expert. Other members are:
Olivier de Frouville, a law professor at l'Université de Montpellier 1 in France; Osman El Hajjé, a law professor and president of the Jinan University Human Rights Centre in Lebanon; and Ariel Dulitzky of Argentina, a clinical law professor at the University of Texas.
Despite her optimism back in 2007, Jaya worried that desired "near-universal ratification" might be hard to come by.
Entry into force, at least, was relatively rapid.
The convention entered into force almost exactly 4 years after being adopted -- on December 23d of last year, 30 days after Iraq became its 20th state party. Today, less than a month later, it now has 21 states parties, Brazil having ratified soon after Iraq. Beside those 2 countries, the other states parties are Albania, Argentina, Bolivia, Burkina Faso, Chile, Cuba, Ecuador, France, Germany, Honduras, Japan, Kazakhstan, Mali, Mexico, Nigeria, Paraguay, Senegal, Spain, and Uruguay.
As pointed out in a U.N. press release respecting the status of the treaty, about 70 other states "have taken the preliminary step of signing it, an expression of their intention to ratify it at some point in the future."
And yet many countries remain fully outside the treaty regime. Among those that have neither signed nor ratified are 4 of the P-5 members: China, Russia, the United Kingdom, and the United States.

Uruguay Supreme Court annuls amnesty law, as accountability continues in Latin America

The Uruguayan Supreme Court made Uruguay the second country in Latin America – after Argentina – to formally annul the amnesty law passed to protect members of the security forces from accusations that they committed torture, disappearance and summary execution during the period of military control (1973-85).
The action taken on Monday by Uruguay's highest court (photo credit) came as the legislature was considering a bill to do the same thing.
Last year, the same court had struck down much of the 1986 amnesty law – Ley de Caducidad de la Pretensión Punitiva del Estado – in a single case involving the 1974 killing of Nibia Sabalsagaray (below left), a literature professor. The current ruling made that decision applicable in all cases. The court’s decision in the earlier case held that Articles 1, 3 and 4 of the amnesty law was unconstitutional because it:
► Violated the separation of powers;
► Did not constitute a valid amnesty; and
► Violated Uruguay’s human rights commitments.
These articles suspended criminal prosecution (Article 1), and gave the executive branch the power to decide whether a particular crime or episode fell within the scope of the amnesty (Articles 3 and 4), thus violating principles of separation of powers and the independence of the judiciary.
In addition, the unanimous decision found that the law interfered with the rights of victims to truth and to judicial process. The court cited the role of international law in Uruguay’s legal system and precedents from neighboring Argentina, as well as the inter-American human rights system’s Commission and Court, in reaching its decision.
What makes the Uruguayan decision particularly interesting is that the Uruguayan public has –twice – rejected a call to overturn the amnesty law via plebiscite.
Uruguayan law allows laws to be overturned if a large number of people call for a plebiscite. Although civil society groups in 2009 managed to gain the required number of signatures to put the issue on the ballot, it lost narrowly. Thus, the Court was acting to uphold legal principles, even in the face of contrary public opinion.
It is unclear how many additional cases will result, since less than 200 forced disappearances or killings took place in Uruguay; most Uruguayans suspected of leftist activity were killed or disappeared in neighboring Argentina. If the courts start taking up torture cases, that will change, since a large number of Uruguayans were tortured during the years of military control. Some of the top leaders of that period, including former presidents Juan Bordaberry and Gregorio Alvarez (right), are already in prison based on earlier cases found not to come within the ambit of the amnesty law. (photo credit)
The court’s decision brings Uruguay into line with its neighbors.
Argentina annulled its amnesty law in 2005, and trials are under way regarding events in the most notorious secret detention centers.
Chile has still not formally annulled its amnesty law. But Chilean courts have not applied the amnesty law to crimes committed by the military or police during the Pinochet regime for several years now.
Brazil remains the sole holdout.
Even though the number of violations in Brazil during the years of dictatorship were relatively low, military officials have taken the position that any effort to bring cases to court is an affront to their institutional role, and would reopen unfinished debates about the legality of the 1964 coup. The Brazilian Supreme Court decided to uphold the amnesty law on grounds that the courts could not interfere with a political decision and that human rights commitments were only acquired subsequent to the crimes and so could not be the basis for overturning the law. Even so, the Brazilian government has paid reparations to victims and survivors, has held investigations, and is discussing a truth commission. Civil society groups and the Caravana da Anistia, the Amnesty Commission within the Justice Ministry, will be pushing the new Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff to take a fresh look at the issue – especially given the increasingly solid regional consensus that formal amnesties, at least, are a thing of the past.

Newest woman head of state

Brazilians have just elected their 1st woman President.
An economist and former Cabinet minister, Dilma Rousseff (right), won a runoff election by a margin of 55.2% to 44.8%.
Key to the political newcomer's victory, according to Reuters: the endorsement of outgoing President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, known as "Lula," coupled with a promise to continue Lula's
policies that have lifted millions from poverty and made Brazil one of the world's hottest economies.
Rousseff replaces Slovakian Prime Minister Iveta Radičová as the newest woman national leader; as posted, in July Radičová seized that mantle from Australian Prime Minister Julia Gillard.

Times They Are A Changing: Developing Countries in the WTO

A few weeks ago, I strode into my law school classroom brimming with hope and optimism. "Brazil is about to retaliate against a U.S. trade measure!" I excitedly reported to my students. Luckily, this was a class on trade and development law, and so my students were equally struck by the news (it wouldn't have gone over so well in say . . . my contracts class!) Brazil poised to retaliate against the United States for an unfair trade action? Unheard of.

As Harvard Professor Robert Z. Lawrence notes, “Traditionally, retaliation in trade has been the preserve of the largest developed countries, which have market power.” To put it bluntly, there has always been an unspoken rule of trade law: Only rich countries get to retaliate against another's violation of trade rules. "Retaliation" in trade parlance simply means that one country receives approval from the WTO to take countermeasures against another for violation of the rules. The most common countermeasure is for the prevailing country to impose more duties on the exports of the losing country. But retaliation comes at some cost for poor countries--either economic or political.

For developing countries who desperately need the exports of more advanced countries, raising duties on these products simply punishes their own citizens who are forced to pay more for the goods (or risk not having them). Moreover, rich countries have an array of subtle and not-so-subtle means of coercion at their disposal to prevent developing countries from raising trade claims in the first place. Much of North-South trade is characterized by "voluntary" concessions--namely, rich countries provide poor ones preferential access to their markets on a non-reciprocal and voluntary basis. One example of this is the U.S.-created African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), which allows duty-free and quota-free imports of some African goods into the U.S. market. But what would happen if Uganda, which is AGOA-certified, were to successfully raise a claim against the U.S. in the WTO? There goes its AGOA benefits. It is perhaps not surprising under the circumstances that no African country has raised a dispute in the WTO.

Developing countries have long faced the frustrating dilemma of a right without a remedy in trade disputes. But suddenly, things are changing. In 2002, Brazil successfully brought action in the WTO against U.S. subsidies to its cotton industry, which averaged $4.9 billion per year. After various appeals, Brazil was finally authorized by the WTO to retaliate against the United States to the tune of $830 million. Perhaps more importantly, Brazil threatened (with WTO support) to suspend intellectual property protection on things like U.S.-manufactured seeds and pharmaceuticals. Suddenly, Washington was taking note.

Just this week, Brazil and the United States announced a settlement of their now eight year old dispute. Brazil will postpone retaliation, and the United States in turn will modify its cotton subsidy program and establish a temporary assistance fund for the Brazilian cotton industry. Brazil's success has demonstrated that the trade rules are not exclusively the purview of the largest developed countries.

My students and I can only wonder what this will mean for the future of world trade.

Guest Blogger: Mireille Delmas-Marty

It’s IntLawGrrls’ immense honor to welcome Dr. Mireille Delmas-Marty (right) as a guest blogger.
Mireille is a Professor at the Collège de France, a Paris institution of higher education founded in the 1500s. Holder of the Chair of Comparative Legal Studies and Internationalization of Law at the Collège, she publishes frequently in that subject area and also directs 3 scholarly networks on the internationalization of law: the French-Chinese, the French-Brazilian, and the French-American (participants have included 4 contributors to IntLawGrrls, Hélène Ruiz Fabri, Vivian Grosswald Curran, Naomi Norberg, and me).
I’ve had the honor of calling Mireille collègue since University of Vienna Law Professor Frank Höpfel, with whom I'd corresponded while researching global developments in criminal procedure for my Harmonic Convergence? article, kindly pointed me to her work. Then a Professor of Law at Université de Paris (Panthéon-Sorbonne), Mireille also was coordinating Corpus Juris, a project aimed at establishing for the European Union a penal code that bridged common law and civil law systems. At the same time, she’s written widely on international criminal law, and on transnational and international developments in other areas of law, among them trade and the environment.
In 1969 Mireille earned her Ph.D. in criminal law from Paris 1, whose law faculty she joined after teaching at Lille and Paris XI. Throughout her career, as detailed in her c.v., she’s been active in many organizations and earned many honors. Among them are honorary doctorates from the universities of Liège, Urbino, Uppsala, Beijing, Louvain, Montreal, and Ferrara. She’s served as a Visiting Professor of Law at universities throughout the world, as Vice President of the International Association of Penal Law, as Editor in Chief and then Director of the Revue de science criminelle et de droit pénal comparé, as a board member of the Journal of International Criminal Justice, and as a legal expert on many committees by appointment of the French government and European entities. Mireille is an Officer in France’s Légion d’Honneur and a Commander in the French National Order of Merit.
Our colleague William A. Schabas, Director of the Irish Centre for Human Rights, gave this succinct yet apt description of Mireille:

She is one of the great thinkers of our time on issues concerning law and society.
As a guest blogger, Mireille contributes a 3-part series -- the 1st post is below -- comparing U.S. and French approaches to the evolving world of transnational law. It outlines ideas that Mireille sets forth in detail in her most recent book, Ordering Pluralism: A Conceptual Framework for Understanding the Transnational Legal World (2009) (prior post), translated into English by IntLawGrrl Naomi Norberg.
For reasons she sets forth in a bilingual guest post further below, Mireille's chosen to honor the abstract painter Maria Helena Vieira da Silva, who joins other foremothers in IntLawGrrls' list just below the "visiting from..." map at right.

Heartfelt welcome!

The Copenhagen Accord: Deal but No Deal

(My thanks to IntLawGrrls for the opportunity to contribute this guest post)

After two years of preparation and two weeks of intense negotiations at the COP 15 in Copenhagen, there is no internationally legally binding deal on climate change. This is not exactly a surprise. Countries, particularly the United States, China and Denmark, were careful to set clear expectations that there would be no such deal in the weeks leading up to the COP. It is, however, disappointing, particularly given the urgency facing those who are already feeling the impacts of global warming.
There is the Copenhagen Accord – a summary of political commitments developed and agreed to in the final hours by the ministerial-level leaders of five nations: Brazil, China, India, South Africa and the United States. The text of the Copenhagen Accord recognizes climate change as “one of the greatest challenges of our time,” and notes the political will to take action immediately to keep the global increase in warming below 2 degrees. It specifies targets and deadlines for Annex I and Non-Annex I countries, and commits developed countries to providing $30 billion in funding over the next two years. It also highlights, albeit in vague language, the need to monitor and verify emission reductions – a sensitive point of negotiation between the United States and China.
The Accord is the result of the efforts of a handful of nations. As high-level ministers arrived last Wednesday and Thursday, they began negotiating in an attempt to reach a deal of some kind. Their efforts were heralded by U.N. Assistant Secretary Robert Orr as “the most genuine negotiation I’ve ever seen between leaders.” Yet in their understandable haste, a select few nations engaged in a process that left most countries out, usurping the traditional negotiation process used by diplomats and civil servants. As a consequence, some of those latter countries sought to block the Copenhagen Accord’s formal acceptance.
But the Copenhagen Accord is an outcome – it is something.
U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki-moon said “finally, we sealed the deal,” while also noting the need to translate the Accord into international law next year. President Obama has called for continued confidence-building before a legally binding deal can be reached. Translation: more meetings. Indeed, although the Copenhagen Accord is deemed “operational immediately,” it will require continued multilateral discussions and cooperation for it to take full effect.
But can we afford to continue COP talks?
The cost alone is staggering. Denmark spent an estimated $350 million on hosting the conference, which allegedly racked up a 41,000-ton carbon footprint. The process is also flawed. It is a time-sink – resulting in a two-year lead-up to a two-week meeting that reached a “deal” in the last two days. Tuvalu’s upset during the first week and the temporary withdrawal by several African nations in the second week were symptomatic of a process in which power triumphs over interests. Simply put, there is a deficit of trust. No country wants to make the first move if it means vulnerability. This is why deals are made in side-negotiations where smaller groups of parties find the assurances they need to “get real.” The lesson of COP 15 – the Accord is the result of such a meeting.
Another lesson worth keeping in mind for next year's climate change summit in Mexico City is this:
Climate change is a global challenge of unprecedented scale, complexity and severity, and as such it demands considering a new kind of process for reaching global solutions. The same old multilateral treaty negotiation process that worked so well in the case of the 1987 Montreal Protocol is not sufficient. Among other things, on the issue of climate change there simply is not enough time.


On August 30

On this day in ...
... 1821, Anita Ribeiro was born in a town in southern Brazil 1 year before it became independent from Portuguese colonizers. She was forced into marriage at age 15; her husband is believed later to have abandoned her. At age 18, she joined forces with Italian revolutionary Giuseppe Garibaldi and became his partner in love and war. They took part in insurgent battles in Brazil and Uruguay. The couple married in 1842. Soon after they went to Italy to join the revolution of 1848. Fighting in the unsuccessful defense of Rome while pregnant with her 5th child, 27-year-old Anita Ribeiro di Garibaldi (right) fell sick and died on August 4, 1849, near Ravenna, during the retreat of the Garibaldian Legion. (credit for 1839 portrait)

(Prior August 30 posts are here and here.)

On August 16

On this day in ...
... 1946, Dorothy Jacobs Bellanca died in New York City, 52 years and 6 days after she'd been born in Zemel, Latvia, the youngest of 4 daughters. In 1900 the family immigrated to Baltimore, where her father worked as a tailor and she attended public schools. Her mother died, and at age 13 Dorothy went to work, hand-sewing buttonholes on men's coat for $3 a week. (As no image of Bellanca appears to exist online, we post above left a photo of New York garment workers performing such work. (credit)) By age 15 she'd "organized female immigrant buttonhole makers into Local 170 of the United Garment Workers of America"; she'd go on to become a leading labor organizer who "promoted class solidarity, but took particular interest in organizing women." During the New Deal era -- at the request of Labor Secretary Frances Perkins, an IntLawGrrls transnational foremother -- she served on the Maternal and Child Welfare Committee. Bellanca also ran to be the Member of Congress representing Brooklyn, losing to the incumbent by a margin of fewer than 16,000 votes out of more than a quarter-million cast. Bellanca recently was featured as "Immigrant of the Day" by our colleagues at Immigration Prof Blog.
... 1869 (140 years ago today), la batallas de Acosta Ñú/Campo Grande, a struggle that had raged for days, took a particularly tragic turn: the massacre of thousands of Paraguayan child soldiers by troops from the Triple Alliance comprising Argentina, Brazil, and Uruguay. Some of the children -- who'd been impressed into service by the leader of Paraguay (flag at right) after many adults were killed or captured -- "fought with fake beards to conceal their age." To this day the event is commemorated as Children's Day in Paraguay.

(Prior August 16 posts are here and here.)

On July 9

On this day in ...
… 1816, an assembly of representatives from the provinces met in the Congress of Tucumán and declared the full independence of the United Provinces of South America (present-day Argentina, flag at right) from the Spanish Crown. Prior to this, Argentina had been part of the Spanish Viceroyalty of the Río de la Plata, whose limits also roughly contained the territories of present-day Bolivia, Paraguay, and Uruguay. It was ruled by a viceroy appointed by the Spanish Crown and guarded by the Spanish royal army. Part of the conflict between the settlers and the crown can be traced to the traditional, full prohibition of trading with all countries except Spain. After the Napoleonic invasion of Spain and the consequent imprisonment of Spain's king, a revolutionary wave broke out in the colony, leading to the declaration of independence on this day. Bolivia and Uruguay subsequently declared independence in 1825 and 1828, respectively. Argentine Independence Day is celebrated annually on July 9 to commemorate this event.
… 1932, the Constitutionalist Revolution of 1932 (sometimes also referred to as the Paulista War), the uprising of part of the population of the Brazilian state of São Paulo against the federal government, began. A response to the Revolution of 1930, which ended the autonomy that São Paulo had enjoyed under the constitution of 1891, the uprising started after 5 protesting students were killed by government troops. A movement then formed; it advocated the overthrow of the federal government and even the secession of São Paulo from the Brazilian federation. Although the São Paulo revolt would be crushed militarily in October, the end of the constitutionalist revolution marked the beginning of the democratization process. The Constitutionalist Revolution is celebrated on this day in the city of São Paulo. (left, a Paulista propaganda poster during the Constitutionalist Revolution; image credit)

(Prior July 9 posts are here and here.)

The work of the U.N. minority issues expert

(My thanks to IntLawGrrls for this opportunity to contribute this guest post on my current work on behalf of the United Nations)

► This week I sent a letter, along with my colleagues who work on torture and arbitrary detention, to China. We challenged the Chinese government either to explain how its detention of two ethnic Uighurs complies with international law or to release the two urgently. China acknowledges having upwards of 40 different ethnic and religious minorities, in addition to the Tibetans, who face varying levels of oppression and repression.
► Next week I leave for a mission to Kazakhstan.
► Last year this time I was in Guyana, investigating the multi-layered relationships between the Indo-Guyanese (persons of East Indian descent), who currently control the government, and the Afro-Guyanese, who are almost the same percentage of the population but feel persecuted and grossly disadvantaged.
► In France, I saw a country that tourists never see. The lives of the “visible minorities” of France, persons who immigrate from North Africa, Asia, and the Caribbean to the shoddy, ghetto suburbs outside Paris, can’t been seen from the Eiffel Tower. They face discrimination at all levels. They are suspected and feared because of their religion. And even those who are second-generation citizens are never, ever considered “French.”
Since 2005, I have done this work in my capacity as U.N. Independent Expert on Minority Issues. I was appointed to the position by the High Commissioner for Human Rights with the consent of all governments that were members of the U.N. Human Rights Council (née Commission on Human Rights). There are over 40 individuals like myself, from all regions of the world, who are chosen to carry out this critical function for the chief human rights mechanism of the United Nations. Each has a mandate to focus on a specific human right. My mandate is to focus on the rights of minority populations. They are defined as groups that are distinct by ethnicity (race), religion or language and who have an inferior power relationship to other groups in the society. The relative numbers aren’t as meaningful as the subservient power status. So that:
► In South Africa during apartheid, my mandate would have been the protection of the African population, rather than the Afrikaners.
► In Brazil, I focus on the Afro-Brazilians even though the government now admits that they may be 55% or more of the population.
Furthermore, the U.N. resolution authorizing my work requires that I take “a gender perspective” in everything that I do. Each year I visit a number of countries where I am received at the level of a Cabinet Member or Minister of State. That gives me an unparalleled opportunity to engage the top officials in countries about their policies regarding minorities. And, of course, I am able to meet with minority communities, with academics who study these issues, and with civil societies more broadly. I present my findings, evaluations and detailed recommendations to the 47 governments that sit on the U.N. Human Rights Council. I also do thematic reports on issues that concern minorities across all regions of the world, like minorities and poverty or minorities and the right to education.
Of course, my mandate also includes minorities in the United States. Indeed, U.S. civil rights laws and my personal experiences as a minority in the United States have enriched my capacity to grapple with the complexities of discrimination as they present themselves in other cultures and countries. When I take on issues here in the United States, however, that home-grown expertise is rarely acknowledged.
An example: The U.N. Special Rapporteur on Housing and I intervened a while back when the City of New Orleans revealed a post-Hurricane Katrina plan to tear down much of the its remaining public housing. Our assessment was that to do that would violate the right to adequate housing that is guaranteed without discrimination by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The local response? New Orleans' daily newspaper, the Times-Picayune, accused me of being a meddling outsider “idiot from the U.N.”

Ensuring access to health care

Last week, I participated in a multi-disciplinary conference, "The Arts, Human Development and Human Rights" at the University of Pittsburgh. (Earlier post.) A week later, an intriguing fact about the Brazilian public health program in the Rio de Janeiro favelas (above) is still bouncing around my mind: the doctor working at each neighborhood clinic visits every single home in her assigned neighborhood. (photo credit)
In fact, she spends half of her work week visiting those homes in turn, one after another, until she has gone to every one – and then she starts over again with the first home.
As someone who has spent some time thinking about access to justice in poor and conflict-ridden settings, this approach to access to public health services caught my attention. It’s a very direct, very proactive approach, and an approach to resource allocation very different from the American strategy for medical care -- or for that matter, than any approach to access to justice that I'm aware of. (Indeed, in this period of détente, I should mention that the Brazilian Family Health Program was modeled on a Cuban initiative.)
These visits are, presumably, a low-cost endeavor in some respects. They rely on observation and conversation rather than expensive technology or tests. But they are high-cost in another way: they devote an enormous amount of time and energy to developing relationships with people who do not necessarily require immediate medical care. These relationships can then be put to many health-directed uses, as well as some broader purposes:
► They can be used to offer preventative health advice and information and to gather public health information.
► They can be used to facilitate and provide a health background for medical care when the need arises.
► And they contribute to other projects in the community – including the Communiarte arts project that was one focus of the conference.
Fundamentally, the Brazilian program places medical care in a relational context and collapses the problem of access into that context.

The arts, human development & human rights

What if participating in the arts can transform not just your sense of self-expression, but also your health and your involvement in your community? Is there potential for synergy between artistic exploration and better health and human rights?
A joint project between Pittsburgh's Andy Warhol Museum and the Museum of Contemporary Art in Niterói, Brazil, explored this question in one of the favela (shantytowns) outside of Rio de Janeiro. Jessica Gogan (left), Director of Special Projects, says:

'The concept of Communiarte is simple: Connect art, health and social justice, give it a supportive framework, and see what happens.'
What happened in this case was an explosion of art, and the documentation and mapping of life in the favela. For lawyers, this approach presents a striking alternative to our often litigation- and lobbying-focused strategy for human rights work.
I'll be learning more about this and, more immediately to hand, about the work of University of Pittsburgh law students in the Pittsburgh Street Law and Human Rights Education Project, in a conference entitled "The Arts, Human Development, and Human Rights," being held at the University of Pittsburgh over the next two days. The conference brings together folks from the Niterói and Pittsburgh projects with educators from the medical school, law school, anthropology department and elsewhere -- all looking to learn from the artists.

Site for Tribal Survival

Want to keep up with the movement for tribal peoples? Log on to Survival International, a multilingual site chock full of information about Brazilian Indians invading the World Social Forum held in late January, or the Awá, some of whom are still "uncontacted," or the Bushmen of Botswana, facing eviction from their lands to make way for diamond mining. You'll find articles and videos concerning tribes in the Americas, Africa and Asia/Australasia, educational materials, ways to contribute (by taking action, donating or buying various items), and a monthly newsletter.
Check it out!

And for more on the WTO ...

... check out this ASIL Insight on the latest development in the trade battle over cotton prices.
That battle began in the last decade, explains the author, Professor Karen Halverson Cross (left) of Chicago’s John Marshall Law School. Brazil complained that subsidies the United States paid its cotton farmers had violated 2 World Trade Organization pacts; in particular, the Agreement on Agriculture. A WTO compliance panel agreed. Cross published on earlier steps in the litigation here; her Insight focuses on the June ruling in which the WTO Appellate Body sustained the compliance panel.
The ruling is unlikely to end the dispute at this time, when broader trade talks have failed, Cross writes. Brazil is expected to resume arbitration in an effort to secure countermeasures – that is, payment in the billions of dollars on account of the United States’ violation – and may even seek to retaliate.
Stay tuned.

"The Pink Bus"

All's rosy on the "pink bus" (left), but apparently not elsewhere in Mexico City.
According to an Associated Press report, harassment of women passengers there has become intolerable. (hat tip; photo credit)
Groping and verbal harassment is an exasperating reality for women using public transportation in this sprawling capital, where 22 million passengers cram onto subways and buses each day.
Personal experience, in the United States and Europe alike, tells me Mexico City's not alone in this problem. To its credit, the city's been working on solutions:

Some men treat women so badly that the subway system has long had ladies-only cars during rush hour, with police segregating the sexes on the platforms.

And the city's just gone one step further, joining transport systems in India, Brazil, and Japan in designating "'ladies only' buses, complete with pink signs in the windshields to wave off the men." Only women and their children are allowed. When a man got on by accident, he was hooted off the bus in a couple stops. At this janitor Yolanda Altamirano, 64, delivered what counts as today's IntLawGrrls' 'Nuff said:

Now he knows how women feel.

Affirmative action and past wrongs

Recognition of past wrongs can take many forms. As posted yesterday, there's the package of compensation, exhumation, and verdict-reversals that comprise Spain's proposed Ley de Memoria Histórica. There're international criminal justice and truth commissions, too. There's the establishment of monuments, lasting reminders that boost public awareness.
And there's affirmative action.
In an EbonyJet.com article entitled "The New Brazil: coming to grips with race - finally," Judith Morrison (above), Regional Director for South America and Caribbean for the Inter-American Foundation, writes that "Brazil has analyzed the experiences of the US, Malaysia and South Africa and has opted to implement affirmative action programs throughout the country." Matilde Ribeiro (below), Secretary for the Promotion of Racial Equality, heads a new, Cabinet-level, government agency. Individual states are considering affirmative action in social programs, and universities have worked to diversify student bodies. "The prestigious Brazilian Foreign Service known as Itamaraty," Morrison writes, "has a quota system to set aside spaces for Afro-Brazilians to study diplomacy." Morrison concludes:

Brazil had long been seen as the model of a unique brand of racial harmony (insidiously called racial democracy) that hid underlying state policies of racial discrimination. Brazil is finally beginning to come to terms with its long history of racism and exclusion through innovative policies and national attention to racial disparities -- it is worthwhile for all of us to study this interesting example.

(Heartfelt thanks to Nekesha Batty for the head's up on this article.)

Treading a green road on trade

Check out the recent ASIL Insight by Julia Qin on the June 2007 "'green' decision" in Brazil – Measures Affecting Imports of Retreaded Tyres.
As Qin (left) explains, the European Communities had brought a challenge against a Brazilian law that bans importation of already-used-but-retreaded tires (right), based on the reasoning that the retreads have a shorter lifespan and so will find their way even sooner into waste heaps where they "create health and enivronmental hazards by providing breeding grounds for mosquite-borne diseases," and further "caus[e] tyre fires that are difficult to control." A panel of the World Trade Organization agreed, perhaps more so than Brazil wished: the panel "effectively directed" Brazil to extend the ban to imports of such tires from countries outside Europe; most notably, MERCOSUR neighbors that'd been permitted to sell the tires in Brazil.
In Qin's view the Brazil - Tyres decision could "become a milestone in WTO jurisprudence on trade and the environment" -- if, that is, it survives review by the WTO's Appellate Body.

On May 13, ....

... 1968, workers joined students and teachers in a 1-day general strike, marching 800,000 strong through the streets of Paris to protest the force with which police had in recent days quelled riots against the government of President Charles de Gaulle. Demonstrations would continue throughout mai 68 and daw as many as 10 million participants throughout France. On May 29 tanks were stationed just outside Paris. The crisis ended when Gaullists won a June election, then moved toward educational reform.
...1888, Princess Isabel (right), acting as Imperial Princess Regent of Brazil in the absence of her father, Emperor Dom Pedro II, promulgated Lei Áurea, the "Golden Law" that abolished slavery in Brazil. According to a UNESCO report: "This provoked an economic chaos since the farmers were not prepared to replace the slave labor by free workers." The monarchy fell 1 year later.
 
Bloggers Team