Showing posts with label Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Liberia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Liberia. Show all posts

Truth Without Teeth

We've blogged here about Liberia's Truth and Reconciliation Commission, a body established to investigate human rights violations during civil conflict in Liberia from 1979 through 2003. The TRC aims to create "an independent, accurate and objective record of the past and make recommendations reflective of the truth to re-unify and reconcile contending groups and/or the peoples of Liberia." There has been grumbling as of late as to whether these lofty goals can be met, perhaps because its teeth are a bit soft and fuzzy -- the TRC's Mandate enables it to "ensure accountability, political or otherwise" for serious human rights violations and to "recommend amnesty" (for crimes other than war crimes and crimes against humanity) under individual applications, but requires the TRC to grant immunity from prosecution "on account of" statements made or evidence presented before it (i.e. such evidence can't be used against the speaker in court). (In perhaps the weirdest marriage of technology and transitional justice I've seen, the TRC's website offers an amnesty application form with jarring questions such as "How would you describe yourself? Witness; Perpetrator; Other" and "Were you a combatant or member of a warring faction?") The result has been, in the words of the TRC's own press release, "a chorus of denials of atrocities by key war actors."
This is seriously troubling for those who suffered human rights abuses under the Doe and Taylor regimes, as well as for those with a principled interest in justice for mass violence. It seems that the TRC's behavioral expectations for former warlords may have been overly sanguine; by offering these perpetrators the ability to tell the truth with impunity, it expected that they would come forward and provide a detailed accounting of their crimes. (In the words of the amnesy application form: "What crime(s) do you believe that you committed? Why did you commit the crimes?") Instead, they may have gotten impunity with no truth; recommended amnesty was not a sufficient carrot without the stick of criminal prosecution. While I'm not arguing that prosecution is a necessary component of transitional justice efforts, future institutions might do well to recognize that they need to offer more than the possibility of amnesty and the guarantee of testimonial immunity to encourage wrongdoers to confess to their crimes. The TRC's ultimate goal is to publish a report cataloguing the crimes perpetrated under the Doe and Taylor regimes; if all it ends up with is a transcript full of denials, it may have done more harm than good to their victims and the nation of Liberia.

Let A Thousand TRCs Bloom

We blogged here about Liberia's Truth and Reconciliation Commission, unusual in that testimony will be taken from Liberian refugees here in the United States for a commission that sits in Africa. South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission was an early incarnation of this transitional justice mechanism, and is often viewed as the model to emulate, though its failure to punish is not without its detractors amongst the families of victims of the apartheid regime. And Sierra Leone's Truth and Reconciliation Commission, complementary to the Special Court for Sierra Leone, has been criticized in some quarters for relying on confession and truth-telling where they're not culturally appropriate. Now, two other African countries are getting in on the action.
Last month, Kenya's parliament approved a Truth, Justice, and Reconciliation Commission to investigate human rights abuses since 1963. While the time frame appears surprisingly long, that's the point -- to investigate "unresolved historical injustices such as distribution of land and state resources, and alleged human rights violations by previous governments and political leaders" that may have been the root cause of the deadly violence resulting from December 2007's disputed elections. The TJRC is hybrid in format, with six Kenyan commissioners and three foreign commissioners drawn from the Panel of African Eminent Personalities, a group of thirteen prominent Africans who helped to negotiate the peace deal in Kenya. It will be complementary to prosecutions of perpetrators of human rights abuses during the post-election violence, either by an international tribunal to be formed in Kenya in the next two months or by the International Criminal Court. Those found guilty of genocide and other human rights violations will not be eligible for amnesty. While the impetus for this denial of amnesty is understandable, particularly in the wake of South Africa's TRC, it may be difficult to prod human rights violators to testify before Kenya's TJRC without the carrot of amnesty. Moreover, critics are already suspicious that politicians seeking to avoid punishment will find an amnesty loophole via the TJRC.
This week, opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai echoed a call made in September by church leaders for a truth and reconciliation commission in Zimbabwe. Tsvangirai believes that a Zimbabwean TRC should examine atrocities in the country dating back to the massacres of ethnic minorities in the 1980s. Church leaders, on the other hand, said that decisions regarding the temporal scope of the TRC should be made by ordinary people, not political parties -- a good rule of thumb for all transitional justice mechanisms. The church leaders found it necessary to air the truth and implement some form of justice in order to heal the nation, and view the South African TRC as their model.
After an initial blossoming of TRCs in Latin America to address the political violence of the 1980s, it's interesting to see this transitional justice mechanism spread throughout Africa. While the South African TRC seemed generally well-tailored to that nation given its religious and legal history and composition, it's not entirely clear that this form of truth-telling will fit all cultural environments. It's surely positive to see the requests for TRCs coming from within these societies, but I query whether there's a more locally grounded moral authority that might be used to account for the violence in Kenya, Zimbabwe, and beyond.

A Hybrid Truth Commission?

In response to criticism of international ad hoc tribunals (too expensive, too distant from the societies they aim to serve) and domestic trials (too biased, insufficient infrastructure) in addressing crimes of mass violence, we've seen the rise of hybrid tribunals that combine elements of international and national structures (think the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia, the Special Court for Sierra Leone). Now we may be seeing a new breed of truth commission. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Liberia, created to examine the causes of the conflict in Liberia from 1979 to 2003, is working with Minnesota Advocates for Human Rights to take statements of Liberians living here in the United States for use before the commission. Indeed, some of this statement-taking will be happening right here in Philadelphia, under the direction of Sarah Paoletti, who runs the new Transnational Clinic at Penn Law. This creative approach enables the cash-strapped Liberian TRC to marshall the resources of American NGOs and law school clinics and to reach populations that fled the country, many because they were targeted by the Doe or Taylor regimes. Liberian refugees as far away as Sweden have expressed interest in being involved in the TRC in this way, and the same organizations that take statements here in the U.S. will also travel to Ghana to assist in statement-taking there. While this approach might be culturally appropriate only for a country with such strong historical ties to the United States, it seems a promising way forward for Liberia, and the engagement of the diaspora may provide useful lessons for future truth commissions around the world. (Photo credit to Richard Franco.)
 
Bloggers Team