Showing posts with label Pervez Musharraf. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pervez Musharraf. Show all posts

... and counting ...

(Occasional sobering thoughts.) Where to start in reviewing war news since our last post on August 21? As we await a planned 1st Presidential debate this evening -- the focus of which is supposed to be foreign policy/national security -- a review of events seems very much in order.

Pakistan
Begin, perhaps, with what appears to be the uncovering of a 3d front for armed conflict involving the United States. It's in Pakistan, where, as IntLawGrrl Naomi Norberg posted on Sunday, a terrorist bomb so devastated part of downtown Islamabad that media there were calling it the country's 9/11. (Excellent posts on same may be found at Steve Coll's blog at The New Yorker website, which I've just discovered. Coll, as IntLawGrrls posted a while back, is the Pulitzer Prizewinning author of a masterful book on U.S.-Pakistan operations pre-9/11.). Today's news from that troubled part of the world, courtesy of the Los Angeles Times: "U.S., Pakistan troops exchange fire on Afghanistan border. The Pentagon calls it a misunderstanding and denies that U.S. helicopters crossed the border into Pakistan's tribal regions." One fears the need soon for a website chronicling casualties there.
(Must say, too, that the man who replaced Pervez Musharraf does not instill confidence that things in Pakistan will improve. This week's flirting by President Asif Ali Zardari -- widower of the assassinated Benazir Bhutto -- with GOP VP candidate Sarah Palin was beyond creepy. (photo credit))

Afghanistan
Move, then, to Afghanistan. A core concern of this recurring feature, civilian casualties, continue to mount:
This year is on pace to be the deadliest for civilians since the Taliban were toppled by the American-led invasion in 2001. More than 1,445 civilians have been killed so far in 2008, and slightly more than half of those deaths, tallied by the United Nations, are attributed to insurgent forces.
This month Robert Gates, U.S. Secretary of Defense, "express[ed] his 'sincere condolences'" to the Afghan people "and promis[ed] speedier compensation and investigation after such casualties." The apology came not long after Afghan leaders demanded a SOFA, or status of forces agreement, spelling out troops' responsibilities. They called for an end to aerial attacks as well. As for average Afghans, it's reported that "As Crime Increases in Kabul, So Does Nostalgia for Taliban." And in Washington, a U.S. National Intelligence Estimate in the works is said to be so "grim" on prospects in Afghanistan that the government plans to keep it secret till after the November 4 election.

Iraq
Shift to Iraq. Violence is by no means over, yet remains less than before. In the United States mainstream media attribute this to "the surge" of added U.S. troops. We've posted in the past that events before the surge might be the major cause. A newly released UCLA study supports that view, "suggesting that ethnic cleansing by rival Shiites may have been largely responsible for the decrease in violence for which the U.S. military has claimed credit." At the negotiating table, meanwhile, it seemed that the United States had reached an agreement that would allow its troops to remain with the Iraqis' OK -- on the condition that plans for eventual withdrawal be included in the agreement. That's stalled, however. Yesterday U.S. officials blamed Iran for the impasse in its talks with Iraq.

The Count
With this news in mind, we move, finally, to the casualty count. According to Iraq Body Count, between 87,643 and 95,664 Iraqi women, children, and men have died in the conflict in Iraq since the U.S.-led invasion in March 2003. That's an increase of between 982 and 1,107 deaths in the last 4 weeks. According to the U.S. Defense Department, 4,172 American servicemembers have been killed in Iraq. Total coalition fatalities: 4,486 persons. That's 27 servicemember deaths in the last 4 weeks, all but 1 of them Americans. On the other established front, military casualties in Afghanistan stand at 605 Americans and 376 other coalition servicemembers. That's an increase of 27 and 16, respectively, in the last 3 weeks, and a total servicemember casualty count just shy of 1,000.

Dépêche du Pakistan: Musharraf resigns

It's official, Pervez Musharraf has resigned. As the IHT reports:

Facing imminent impeachment charges, Musharraf announced his resignation on Monday, after months of belated recognition by American officials that he had become a waning asset in the campaign against terrorism.
The decision removes from Pakistan's political stage the leader who for nearly nine years served as one of the United States' most important — and ultimately unreliable — allies. And it now leaves American officials to deal with a new, elected coalition that has so far proved itself to be unwilling or unable to confront an expanding Taliban insurgency determined to topple the government.

A top item on the agenda, along with choosing a new president within 30 days, is reinstating the 60 judges Musharraf fired. (See below for more on what may be next.)

Next in Pakistan?

Need a a thought-provoking take on what's in store now that Pervez Musharraf's resigned Pakistan's Presidency, as IntLawGrrl Naomi Norberg posts above?
Then take a look at Le Monde's interview with Mariam Abou Zahab (left). She's a Pakistan expert at Sciences Po. The interview's titled "La relation entre les Etats-Unis et le Pakistan ne va pas beaucoup changer" -- that is, "Relations between the United States and Pakistan aren't going to change much."
Why not?
Because, Abou Zahab says, of the ongoing U.S. campaign against terrorism, one that requires working with Pakistan's army, no matter who sit in Pakistan's President's office.

Benazir Bhutto (1953-2007)

Posted just a few short months ago about an essay that Benazir Bhutto had published in Huffington Post. We posted yesterday on her assassination, at age 54, in Rawalpindi, the city where her father was executed in 1979. He too had been Prime Minister of Pakistan.
Efforts to try to process this news have recalled parts of her essay. She wrote:

Pakistan is truly at a turning point. Almost a decade of military dictatorship has devastated the basic infrastructure of democracy. Political parties have been assaulted, political leaders arrested, and the judicial system manipulated to force party leaders into exile. NGOs have been under constant attack, especially those that deal with human rights, democratic values and women's rights. ... And in the battle against terrorism, we look on with dismay as the government of Pakistan ceded sections of our nation that previously had been governed by the rule of law to Taliban sympathizers and to Al Qaeda ....

She wrote of

a growing sense of hopelessness of the people of Pakistan, and a total disillusionment with the political system's ability to address their daily problems.

She worried

that extremism has been making inroads against moderation amongst the Pakistani polity. I have always believed that the battle between extremism and moderation is the underlying battle for the very soul of Pakistan. Yet moderation can prevail against the extremists only if democracy flourishes and the social sector improves the quality of life of the people.

She wrote of relations with incumbent President Pervez Musharraf:

I had a choice. Engage in dialogue, or turn toward the streets. I knew that street protests against the Musharraf dictatorship could lead to the deaths of hundreds. I thought about the choice before me very carefully. I chose dialogue; I chose negotiation; I chose to find a common ground that would unite all the moderate elements of Pakistan for a peaceful transfer to a workable political system ....

She asked:

Are we making progress towards that goal? I still am unable to say.

She returned to her country, and persevered despite immediate violence, despite Musharraf's declaration of a state of emergency in which human rights lawyers were among those detained. Before returning, she recalled her father's fate:

When my democratically elected father, Prime Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was arrested in 1977 and subsequently murdered, the mantle of leadership of the Pakistan Peoples Party, our nation's largest, nationwide grassroots political structure, was suddenly thrust upon me. It was not the life I planned, but it is the life I have. My husband and children accept and understand that my political responsibilities to the people of Pakistan come first, as painful as that personally is to all of us.

She concluded:

I didn't choose this life. It chose me.

Not nearly enough said by this woman, who in 1988 had become "the first woman to lead a modern Muslim country."

"Human rights v. American national security"

Can't let last week's presidential debate recede into dim memory without taking note of an interesting colloquy on the role of human rights in today's political discourse.
Eventually enveloping 5 of the contenders for the Democratic nomination, the discussion began when the moderator, Wolf Blitzer, questioned the call of Gov. Bill Richardson (New Mexico) (left) to cut off military aid to Pakistan unless its President, Gen. Pervez Musharraf, moves "to restore the constitution, take off his military uniform, end the national state of emergency and have free and fair elections." Here's the response:

RICHARDSON: ... [W]hat happened with our Pakistan policy, we got our principles wrong. ... [W]e said to Musharraf: 'You know, Musharraf, security is more important than human rights.' If I'm president, it's the other way around -- democracy and human rights. ...
....
BLITZER: What you're saying, Governor, is that human rights, at times, are more important than American national security?
RICHARDSON: Yes, because I believe we need to find ways to say to the world that, you know, it's not just about what Halliburton wants in Iraq. It's also about our values of freedom, equality. Our strength is not just military and economic. ... Our strength as a nation is our values: equality ... freedom, democracy ... human rights.

Asked "to weigh in," former Sen. John Edwards (North Carolina) dodged the human-rights-versus-national-security dichotomy posited, and so in turning to Sen. Barack Obama (Illinois) (right), the moderator homed in on that question:
BLITZER: ... [I]s human rights more important than American national security?
OBAMA: The concepts are not contradictory, Wolf.
BLITZER: Because occasionally, they could clash.
OBAMA: They are complementary. And I think Pakistan is a great example. Look, we paid $10 billion over the last seven years and we had two goals: deal with terrorism and restore democracy. And we've gotten neither. ... Pakistan's democracy would strengthen our battle against extremists.
The more we see repression, the more there are no outlets for how people can express themselves and their aspirations, the worse off we're going to be, and the more anti-American sentiment there's going to be in the Middle East. We keep on making this mistake. ... And that's going to make us less safe.

Then it was the turn of Sen. Christopher Dodd (Massachusetts) (left):

BLITZER: What is more important, human rights or national security?
DODD: Obviously, national security, keeping the country safe. When you take the oath of office on January 20, you promise to do two things, and that is to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States and protect our country against enemies both foreign and domestic. The security of the country is number one, obviously.

Finally, the moderator turned from Dodd to Sen. Hillary Clinton (New York) (left):
BLITZER: You say national security is more important than human rights. Senator Clinton, what do you say?
CLINTON: I agree with that completely. The first obligation of the president of the United States is to protect and defend the United States of America. That doesn't mean that it is to the exclusion of other interests.
And there's absolutely a connection between a democratic regime and heightened security for the United States. That's what's so tragic about this situation. After 9/11, President Bush had a chance to chart a different course, both in Pakistan and in Afghanistan, and could have been very clear about what our expectations were.
A few comments about this colloquy.
1st, there's the matter of the President's oath, which both Dodd and Clinton misremembered. See below.
2d, there's cause to be disturbed in the degree to which some contenders acceded to the moderator's insistence that "human rights" and "American national security" are at odds with each other, that they "clash" in a manner that demands abstract prioritization of one over the other. Seemed clear to him, at least, that "American national security," standing alone, is the lone right answer. Little need, then, to consider precise context, let alone the security of other states, let alone the security of humanity as a whole. To be commended are those who said otherwise -- who resisted playing the moderator's zero-sum game and instead suggested that in the reinforcement of human rights may be found national security and that, conversely, national security ought to encompass human rights.
Only by acknowledging the complexity of the contemporary world can America's leaders hope truly to improve it.

State of Emergency in Pakistan

400-500 people have already been arrested since Pakistan's President Pervez Musharraf declared a state of emergency just after midnight this morning, most of them opposition leaders, lawyers and rights’ activists. (Photo: B.K. Bangash for AP)
Many major news stations, including international channels like the BBC and CNN were suspended and the Supreme Court was shut down. The Court was to rule shortly on the legality of Musharraf’s reelection; Musharraf claims it has released 61 men being investigated for terrorism. Quoting Abraham Lincoln, Musharraf claimed the emergency – and related rights limitations – were necessary to limit terrorist attacks and, oddly, to "preserve the democratic transition" he claims to have initiated 8 years ago in taking power from the elected president in a bloodless coup. (Video of Musharraf's invocation, in English, of Lincoln is available just below this post; Diane's comments on that invocation are just below the video.)
Now, let’s take a look for a moment at international law and Musharraf's claim:
The purpose of a state of emergency is, indeed, to preserve democracy when it is threatened. That is, a state whose existence (or existence as a democratic state) is threatened may declare a state of emergency and take measures that restrict certain fundamental rights, with the sole purpose of restoring the status quo as quickly as possible. Under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights of 1966, the state must follow certain procedures for its declaration of an emergency to be legal. To be legitimate, the measures it takes must be necessary and proportionate to the danger. “Proportionate” refers not only to the harshness of the measures, but to their duration and territorial reach. In sum, a state of emergency is supposed to be a short-lived shift in the normal democratic balance of power, both between branches of government and government and the people, deemed necessary to recover from a crisis.
Pakistan is not a party to the Covenant, but I would argue that the theory of emergency powers and the rule that rights’ limiting measures must be necessary and proportionate have been around so long and cited so broadly (if, like torture, more often respected in the breach than in practice) that this rule now amounts to custom. In addition to these rules, a state of emergency is seen as illegitimate and fast-heading towards a dictatorship when democratic institutions – particularly the judiciary – are imperiled. Besides arresting about 80 lawyers, Musharraf removed the entire Supreme Court and swore in four “loyal” justices, and replaced judges in the regional High Courts as well. Opposition lawyers claim, however, that the 4 new Supreme Court justices were the only ones the government could find out of the 17 available who would accept being sworn in. In addition, the parliamentary elections planned for January 2008 have been postponed, perhaps for a year. When Parliament stops functioning independently, what UN special rapporteur Leandro Despouy calls “institutional degradation” sets in and democracy, far from being restored, is paralyzed by the state of emergency.
Now, in the first report I read this morning (which is no longer online), I could have sworn I read Condoleezza Rice being quoted as saying that the US would not be able to support Musharraf’s move. Reports a few hours later say that the US is not suspending its aid to the Pakistani military. Considering the illegality and illegitimacy under international law of the now 6-year-old US state of emergency with respect to the 9/11 attacks (unlike Pakistan, the US is a party to the International Covenant) (see, for ex., Diane Marie Amann, “Le dispositif américain de lutte contre le terrorisme”, Revue de Science Criminelle, 2002-4, 745-764; my dissertation on the subject may not ever be published), the Bush administration’s continued military support during Pakistan’s self-induced crisis is disappointing, but somehow, not a surprise.

On Musharraf on Lincoln

As discussed in Naomi's excellent post above, Gen. Pervez Musharraf has called upon the spirit of Abraham Lincoln in an effort to justify declaring a state of emergency in Pakistan.
The invocation of Lincoln (right), the President who governed America at a time when its States were not United -- who saw a 4-year Civil War to its end in 1865 -- has taken the blogosphere by storm. With a hat tip to New York Times blogger Robert Mackey, that segment of Musharraf's speech is available in video above. Full text of the speech is here; here's what Musharraf (below) said about Lincoln:
I would at this time venture to read out an excerpt of President Abraham Lincoln, specially to all my listeners in the United States. As an idealist, Abraham Lincoln had one consuming passion during that time of crisis, and this was to preserve the Union… towards that end, he broke laws, he violated the Constitution, he usurped arbitrary power, he trampled individual liberties. His justification was necessity and explaining his sweeping violation of Constitutional limits he wrote in a letter in 1864, and I quote, 'My oath to preserve the Constitution imposed on me the duty of preserving by every indispensable means that government, that Nation of which the Constitution was the organic law. Was it possible to lose the Nation and yet preserve the Constitution?'
The transcript's from the post by Mackey, who also links to Lincoln's actual words.
What to say about all this?
1st, with regard to "emergency": Lincoln acted after a sizable portion of his country seceded from the Union, donned uniforms, and made war against Union fortresses within the seceded territories. The situation stands on a different plane from the political demonstrations and occasions of terrorist action that Pakistan's faced these last months. Musharraf's regime well have been under threat, given the awaiting decision on whether his re-election was valid, and the new in-country presence of a longtime political opponent, Benazir Bhutto (left), the woman who seeks once again to become the Pakistan's Prime Minister. But it's basic to the derogation rules Naomi discusses that the threat must be to the nation itself, and not simply to the state regime in power in that nation.
2d, with regard to Pakistan and post-9/11 United States: One senses that Musharraf invokes Lincoln because he cannot invoke Bush; that is, he looks to a U.S. President with unquestioned credibility as a source of justification. Yet even an analogy with President George W. Bush (right) would not well serve. The article of mine that Naomi so kindly cites (like my English-language article Guantánamo) questions whether, and if so, how long, the United States suffered such a threat post-9/11. It further criticizes the Bush Administration for acting as if there were a state of emergency yet refusing to discharge its obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. Those obligations:
-- Give precise and proper notice of what emergency measures it was taking (as Britain, incidentally, did); and
-- Tailor those measures precisely to the threat posed, both by limiting suspensions of liberty to the absolute minimum required and by ending all such suspensions as soon as the political climate
permitted.
3d, with regard to the tailoring, or proportionality, of measures by Musharraf, Bush, and Lincoln: In the U.S. periods under review there was, as there now appears to be in Pakistan, neither any wholesale suspension of the Constitution nor any dismissal of the Supreme Court. It is true that there were in the United States curtailments of recourse to habeas corpus. As we've posted, Lincoln's abrogation of the writ remains controversial to this day, and may well prove a point of discussion during the December 5 oral argument before the Supreme Court in the Boumediene challenge to Bush's Guantánamo detention policy. Yet in neither period did U.S. emergency measures go much further than that. It is true that Bush has sought to stave off judicial review of his measures, and in the Detainee Treatment Act and Military Commissions Act Congress has tried to helped him keep the courts at bay. Yet even when the U.S. judiciary brushed aside those efforts, as did the Supreme Court in Hamdan, neither political branch has suggested anything like shutting down the courts. Nor did Chief Justice Roger B. Taney's clash with Lincoln over habeas corpus result in dismissal of Taney (left) or any other member of the Court.
Try as he might, Musharraf can find no refuge in the words of American Presidents, present or past.

Pakistan

This headline in the Hindustan Times says it all: "Karachi carnage mars Bhutto's return." Indeed, "two explosions killed 134 people and wounded 450," the New York Times writes, adding that the "explosions took place just feet from a truck in which Ms. Bhutto was traveling during a triumphal procession marking her return to Pakistan after eight years in exile."
IntLawGrrls've posted often about Bhutto, the 1st woman to serve as Prime Minister in a Muslim country (though perhaps not the 1st PM twice to be deposed on charges of corruption) and her efforts to seek a 3d term. Given recent turmoil in the country, ruled since 1999 by Gen. Pervez Musharraf, yesterday's tragedy is not entirely a surprise. But it calls for questions about Pakistan's security forces, forces whose conduct, painstakingly detailed in Ghost Wars (2004), Steve Coll's Pulitzer Prizewinning study of pre-September 11 counterterrorism practices, remains controversial enough recently to have played a role in Musharraf's effort to oust Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry and to have forced Pakistani author Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa to flee her country. Despite reputed ruthlessness, security forces did not prevent yesterday's tragedy. No surprise, either, then, that Bhutto, who says that days ago she gave Musharraf names of those plotting against her, today is raising questions.

On October 12, ...

... 1915, amid World War I, Edith Cavell was executed by a German firing squad at the National Rifle Range in Brussels. The killing of Cavell, right, a 50-year-old British nurse working in Belgium under the auspices of the Red Cross, followed her conviction for having harbored and aided the escape of Allied soldiers.
... 1999, The Chief of the Army, Gen. Pervez Musharraf, seized control of Pakistan in a bloodless coup that ousted Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif. Eventually Musharraf was elected President, while Sharif and another former Prime Minister, Benazir Bhutto, went into exile. The country's been in turmoil this year, as we've posted. Last Saturday Musharraf won a new term in an election that The Economist condemns as "[u]nrepresentative, rigged and at gunpoint." And though Musharraf managed in September to rebuff Sharif's attempt to return from exile, his bids to fend off Bhutto's promise to come home Oct. 18 seem not to be nearly as successful.

Bhutto in her own words

If you've been following politics in Pakistan, as IntLawGrrls has here, you know that former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto (left) is on the verge of returning home -- and that General/President Pervez Musharraf's less than thrilled at the prospect.
Bhutto tells why she's about to end self-exile in this Huffington Post essay. Her bottom line's a political PR classic:
I didn't choose this life. It chose me.

Pretty good news from the war zone

As Afghan President Hamid Karzai opened the Afghani-Pakistani jirga (tribal council) for peace Thursday, tens of thousands of Shiite pilgrims marched peacefully through Baghdad to a shrine honoring an 8th-century imam, with little of the violence that has marred past celebrations. The only hitch was that Pakistan’s president, General Pervez Musharraf stayed home from the jirga to ponder the need for a state of emergency. Ceding to media, political and diplomatic pressure, he didn’t declare one. His absence from the jirga is not considered a major hurdle to peace building by Afghan officials, as more than 600 tribal leaders, the true power brokers in the region, are in attendance. Tribal elders from Pakistan’s most volatile region are not in attendance either, however, which may lessen the effect of the 4-day meeting, an idea hatched by presidents Bush, Karzai and Musharaff to calm the bloodshed. In an impassioned, if macho, plea to stop the killing, Karzai said the Taliban’s killing of women is tarnishing Afghanistan’s reputation: "It doesn't matter if they kidnap thousands of men, they abducted women!" he said, referring to the South Korean hostages. In reference to other attacks, he said:
"They behead women in the name of the Taliban and Muslims in this country. In Helmand, one woman was nailed to a tree. In Zhari, they cut a woman in half”.
Karzai believes that if Pakistani and Afghan “brothers” unite, the "disaster and cruelty in the two nations will be finished in one day." If over 600 tribal elders can agree on that, perhaps the end is in sight.

The 400 Blows? Disappeared in Pakistan

In an item on Pakistan, the IHT reports:
Every two weeks in crowded sessions of the Supreme Court, judges listen to the pleadings of women demanding to know the whereabouts of their husbands and sons and brothers, who they believe are locked up in government jails and safe houses.
Under pressure from the American government, the Pakistani military and intelligence services have been rounding up and holding incommunicado men who show signs of strong religious convictions, such as wearing full beards, without charging them under applicable law. The list of missing men remains at a fairly constant 400, as released detainees are replaced by new ones. Of the 60 released so far, many report having been tortured. The reports of course get little press, but that suits most of these men, who are too frightened to speak out. In addition, there may be thousands more men being secretly held for supporting the separatist movement in Baluchistan province. Despite the suspension of Chief Justice Chaudhry (right) back in March, perhaps due to his promise to continue hearings until all the detainees are freed, the remaining justices continue to hear the cases. Chaudhry’s challenge to General Musharraf seems to have weakened the General’s standing and strengthened a popular movement to return to civilian rule. We applaud the women and other human rights defenders who are publicly demonstrating and seeking judicial resolution of these cases, as well as the judges who continue to hear them.
 
Bloggers Team