Showing posts with label Benazir Bhutto. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Benazir Bhutto. Show all posts

Introducing Jocelyn Wolf

Eagle-eyed IntLawGrrls readers will have noticed a new byline gracing many of our "On This Day" posts this month. It belongs to Jocelyn Wolf (right), whom we're proud to welcome as the inaugural IntLawGrrls Legal Intern.
A member of the Class of 2011 at my own home institution, the University of California, Davis, School of Law (Martin Luther King, Jr. Hall), Jocelyn has an avid interest in international law, policy, and practice. Whetting her appetite was a semester abroad at the National University of Ireland-Galway in fall 2007. There she studied European Communities law with Dr. Laurent Pech, Jean Monnet Lecturer in EU Law and a contributing editors of International Law Prof Blog. (Jocelyn reports that she was fortunate to have used the used the EU Law textbook for which IntLawGrrl guest/alumna Gráinne de Búrca is a co-author.) Soon after, in spring 2008, Jocelyn earned her B.A. in International Relations and Linguistics from the University of California at Davis. This past semester, she was my student in Constitutional Law.
Jocelyn has chosen to dedicate her work on the blog to Benazir Bhutto (below left), the subject of many earlier IntLawGrrls posts. The U.N. General Assembly bestowed upon Bhutto a U.N. Prize in the Field of Human Rights in December 2008, a year after death ended her campaign to lead her native Pakistan once again. As stated in a 2008 account of that award:

An ardent advocate for democracy and for the human rights of the most vulnerable sections of society, particularly women, children and minority rights, Ms. Bhutto was twice elected prime minister of Pakistan. After returning to Pakistan late last year following years in exile, Ms. Bhutto was assassinated in an attack in Rawalpindi.
Today Bhutto -- whose assassination is currently the subject of a 6-month U.N. inquiry -- joins other IntLawGrrls transnational foremothers in the list just below the "visiting from ..." map at right.
Heartfelt welcome!

... and counting ...

(Occasional sobering thoughts.) Where to start in reviewing war news since our last post on August 21? As we await a planned 1st Presidential debate this evening -- the focus of which is supposed to be foreign policy/national security -- a review of events seems very much in order.

Pakistan
Begin, perhaps, with what appears to be the uncovering of a 3d front for armed conflict involving the United States. It's in Pakistan, where, as IntLawGrrl Naomi Norberg posted on Sunday, a terrorist bomb so devastated part of downtown Islamabad that media there were calling it the country's 9/11. (Excellent posts on same may be found at Steve Coll's blog at The New Yorker website, which I've just discovered. Coll, as IntLawGrrls posted a while back, is the Pulitzer Prizewinning author of a masterful book on U.S.-Pakistan operations pre-9/11.). Today's news from that troubled part of the world, courtesy of the Los Angeles Times: "U.S., Pakistan troops exchange fire on Afghanistan border. The Pentagon calls it a misunderstanding and denies that U.S. helicopters crossed the border into Pakistan's tribal regions." One fears the need soon for a website chronicling casualties there.
(Must say, too, that the man who replaced Pervez Musharraf does not instill confidence that things in Pakistan will improve. This week's flirting by President Asif Ali Zardari -- widower of the assassinated Benazir Bhutto -- with GOP VP candidate Sarah Palin was beyond creepy. (photo credit))

Afghanistan
Move, then, to Afghanistan. A core concern of this recurring feature, civilian casualties, continue to mount:
This year is on pace to be the deadliest for civilians since the Taliban were toppled by the American-led invasion in 2001. More than 1,445 civilians have been killed so far in 2008, and slightly more than half of those deaths, tallied by the United Nations, are attributed to insurgent forces.
This month Robert Gates, U.S. Secretary of Defense, "express[ed] his 'sincere condolences'" to the Afghan people "and promis[ed] speedier compensation and investigation after such casualties." The apology came not long after Afghan leaders demanded a SOFA, or status of forces agreement, spelling out troops' responsibilities. They called for an end to aerial attacks as well. As for average Afghans, it's reported that "As Crime Increases in Kabul, So Does Nostalgia for Taliban." And in Washington, a U.S. National Intelligence Estimate in the works is said to be so "grim" on prospects in Afghanistan that the government plans to keep it secret till after the November 4 election.

Iraq
Shift to Iraq. Violence is by no means over, yet remains less than before. In the United States mainstream media attribute this to "the surge" of added U.S. troops. We've posted in the past that events before the surge might be the major cause. A newly released UCLA study supports that view, "suggesting that ethnic cleansing by rival Shiites may have been largely responsible for the decrease in violence for which the U.S. military has claimed credit." At the negotiating table, meanwhile, it seemed that the United States had reached an agreement that would allow its troops to remain with the Iraqis' OK -- on the condition that plans for eventual withdrawal be included in the agreement. That's stalled, however. Yesterday U.S. officials blamed Iran for the impasse in its talks with Iraq.

The Count
With this news in mind, we move, finally, to the casualty count. According to Iraq Body Count, between 87,643 and 95,664 Iraqi women, children, and men have died in the conflict in Iraq since the U.S.-led invasion in March 2003. That's an increase of between 982 and 1,107 deaths in the last 4 weeks. According to the U.S. Defense Department, 4,172 American servicemembers have been killed in Iraq. Total coalition fatalities: 4,486 persons. That's 27 servicemember deaths in the last 4 weeks, all but 1 of them Americans. On the other established front, military casualties in Afghanistan stand at 605 Americans and 376 other coalition servicemembers. That's an increase of 27 and 16, respectively, in the last 3 weeks, and a total servicemember casualty count just shy of 1,000.

5 Women Buried Alive in Pakistan

The honor killing six weeks ago in Baluchistan province (flag at left) of 3 young women intending to marry men of their choice and 2 older female relatives has sparked widespread protest and a political dispute as to the propriety of the practice. The French human rights group International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) reports that the 5 women were kidnapped by several men who beat and shot the young women, then, though they were still breathing, buried them under earth and stones. Because they tried to intervene, the 2 older women were also buried alive (no one seems to know what's happened to the 3 bridegrooms). The kidnappers reportedly drove a vehicle with a provincial government license plate and included a brother of the Baluchistan housing minister, who is a member of the Pakistan Peoples Party (Benazir Bhutto's party). When Yasmeen Shah, an opposition senator, accused the government of ignoring and perhaps covering up the incident (because Baluchistan's support was important for the party in the recent presidential elections that put Bhutto's widower, Asif Ali Zardari, in power), a senator from the province interrupted her, defending honor killings as a local norm and claiming they should "not be highlighted negatively." While the public outcry has produced governmental support for a Senate resolution condemning the killings and an inquest, the Interior Ministry doesn't seem convinced of the motive: a senior ministry official was quoted as saying he thinks the killings result from a land dispute and expects the inquest to be finished within a week.
In 2004, Pakistan outlawed honor killings, making them a capital crime. But critics warned then that the law was weak and rights groups say that it is ineffective: hundreds of women are killed every year in Pakistan in the name of honor, though few are the killings that are reported or properly investigated. The problem is not limited to Pakistan, of course. The International Campaign Against Honour Killings reports that, like the woman in the photo destined to be stoned to death (photo credit):
"Over 5000 women and girls are killed every year by family members in so-called "honour killings," according to the UN . These crimes occur where cultures believe that a woman's unsanctioned sexual behaviour brings such shame on the family than any female accused or suspected must be murdered. Reasons for these murders can be as trivial as talking to a man, or as innocent as suffering rape."
The phrase "where cultures believe" is misleading, however. For one thing, when people move, cultures move, and migrants have brought so-called honor killings to the United States and countries in Western Europe, where, as we've posted here and here, some judges are having trouble distinguishing between respecting cultural traditions/religious freedom and condoning violence against women. Moreover, as the Magdalene Sisters and perhaps even the upcoming marriage of VP nominee Sarah Palin's pregnant daughter reveal, none of us can be complacent with respect to our own "cultural practices" that punish women for their sexuality.

On June 21

On this day in ...
... 1953 (55 years ago today), Benazir Bhutto was born in Karachi, Pakistan. Bhutto (left) would twice serve as her country's Prime Minister. Last December, an assassin's bullet ended her 3d bid for that position. Prior IntLawGrrls posts here.
... 1973 (35 years ago today), reviewing a conviction for unsolicited mailing of sexually explicit materials, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Miller v. California. By a vote of 5-4, it held that the 1st Amendment to the Constitution does not protect "obscenity"; that is, material that, in the view of jurors: (1) would be seen, "as a whole," by "the average person, applying contemporary community standards," to "appea[l] to the prurient interest"; (2) "depicts or describes, in a patently offensive way, sexual conduct specifically defined by the applicable state law"; and (3) "taken as a whole, lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value."

Gold's glittering, and that's not a good thing

Needn't have expertise in economics to see that things aren't looking so good these days.
Proving by their presence the weakness of the $US were the many foreign shoppers who last month filled holiday-decorated aisles of America's high-end stores, snapping up luxury items that exchange rates have turned into bargain buys. Trouble's evident in every "PRICE REDUCED" banner plastered over a "For Sale" sign -- not to mention those vacated, unsaleable foreclosure houses in old inner cities and new exurbias. (See here, here, here) So too in the increased co-payments for workers lucky enough to have employer-supported health insurance, not to mention the increase in women, children, and men (at last count "[n]early 47 million Americans, or 16 percent of the population") who have no health insurance at all. There's the ever-higher cost of foodstuffs, fueled by the ever-higher cost of the fuel that brings them to market. And there's California, the state whose economy is larger than that of all but a handful of countries, where just-proposed budget cuts threaten "the state's ability to protect children, renters, workers and the elderly as well as California's wildlife and its land."
Now comes evidence of a global economic slide.
In an article entitled "L'or flambe et affirme son rôle de valeur refuge (Gold Catches Fire and Reaffirms Its Role As a Value Refuge)," Le Monde reports that the price of an ounce of gold has just reached record highs of $900.10 on the New York Exchange, $898 in Hong Kong, and $897.90 in London. That's a 32% increase in price during the course of 2007.
Behind the rise, according to Le Monde, is a host of global uncertainties, among them:
the assassination of Benazir Bhutto and fears spurred by the thought of Islamists gaining control of Pakistan's nuclear weapons; the degree to which the United States is bogged down in Iraq; fears of recession in the United States; crises in the banking system of Western countries and a crisis of liquidity; falling real estate prices; and tumbling stock exchange prices.
These are indicators of impending inflation, Le Monde writes. Buyers with the wherewithal to buy are turning to the traditional hedges against that inflation, gold and jewelry. So the costs of both are on the rise.
Sounds like all the more reason for the folks who do have the expertise to start working some economic magic.

Daughters of Pakistani human rights lawyer Asma Jahangir beaten, threatened with death



The Asian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) has reported that the two daughters of human rights lawyer and UN Special Rapporteur Asma Jahangir, along with several friends, were attacked and threatened with death “by armed persons of the Pakistan Muslim League Q (PML-Q),” the ruling party, who claimed to be policemen. Two of them apparently were.

The daughters and their friends had been filming the ripped posters and banners of political parties after the assassination of Benazir Bhutto. When Asma Jahangir learned that they had been detained at the PML-Q party office she went there immediately, but was refused entry -- the armed men "physically restrained her and threatened her with their guns." As the AHRC indicates, though, she gained entry by managing

  • “to climb the iron gate of the party office” where “she saw that her eldest daughter and her friends were detained by more than ten armed persons”
  • she also saw that her youngest daughter was being dragged into a separate room.
  • She immediately informed the police, who took the side of the armed men.
  • The police pressured the parents of the friends “that they should not report this incident otherwise the girls would be kidnapped, raped and killed.”
  • “The police also pressured the parents to stop Ms. Asma Jehangir from making this incident know and claimed that she would bear the responsibility for whatever might happen in the future.”

One of the most prominent human rights lawyers in Pakistan, Asma Jahangir is chair of the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan, current UN Special Rapporteur on the right to freedom of religion or belief, and former UN Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions. The full text of AHRC press statement is available here.

Benazir Bhutto (1953-2007)

Posted just a few short months ago about an essay that Benazir Bhutto had published in Huffington Post. We posted yesterday on her assassination, at age 54, in Rawalpindi, the city where her father was executed in 1979. He too had been Prime Minister of Pakistan.
Efforts to try to process this news have recalled parts of her essay. She wrote:

Pakistan is truly at a turning point. Almost a decade of military dictatorship has devastated the basic infrastructure of democracy. Political parties have been assaulted, political leaders arrested, and the judicial system manipulated to force party leaders into exile. NGOs have been under constant attack, especially those that deal with human rights, democratic values and women's rights. ... And in the battle against terrorism, we look on with dismay as the government of Pakistan ceded sections of our nation that previously had been governed by the rule of law to Taliban sympathizers and to Al Qaeda ....

She wrote of

a growing sense of hopelessness of the people of Pakistan, and a total disillusionment with the political system's ability to address their daily problems.

She worried

that extremism has been making inroads against moderation amongst the Pakistani polity. I have always believed that the battle between extremism and moderation is the underlying battle for the very soul of Pakistan. Yet moderation can prevail against the extremists only if democracy flourishes and the social sector improves the quality of life of the people.

She wrote of relations with incumbent President Pervez Musharraf:

I had a choice. Engage in dialogue, or turn toward the streets. I knew that street protests against the Musharraf dictatorship could lead to the deaths of hundreds. I thought about the choice before me very carefully. I chose dialogue; I chose negotiation; I chose to find a common ground that would unite all the moderate elements of Pakistan for a peaceful transfer to a workable political system ....

She asked:

Are we making progress towards that goal? I still am unable to say.

She returned to her country, and persevered despite immediate violence, despite Musharraf's declaration of a state of emergency in which human rights lawyers were among those detained. Before returning, she recalled her father's fate:

When my democratically elected father, Prime Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was arrested in 1977 and subsequently murdered, the mantle of leadership of the Pakistan Peoples Party, our nation's largest, nationwide grassroots political structure, was suddenly thrust upon me. It was not the life I planned, but it is the life I have. My husband and children accept and understand that my political responsibilities to the people of Pakistan come first, as painful as that personally is to all of us.

She concluded:

I didn't choose this life. It chose me.

Not nearly enough said by this woman, who in 1988 had become "the first woman to lead a modern Muslim country."

Bhutto Assassinated

Benazir Bhutto, twice prime minister of Pakistan and leading opponent of President Musharraf, was assassinated at a rally today. See our recent discussions of Bhutto here, here, here and here, explaining her return from exile and attempts by opponents to silence her. May she rest in peace.

Bhutto and Suu Kyi briefly swap places

With the road leading to her home blocked by barbed wire, metal barricades and dozens of police officers, Benazir Bhutto, former Prime Minister and major opponent of Pakistan’s General Pervez Musharraf, was kept yesterday from attending a rally. Bhutto had intended to lead demonstrators in protest against the week-old state of emergency (see our discussion of states of emergency in posts below by Diane, Michelle, Fiona, myself and again Fiona), but found herself confined for the day. She was, however, able to meet with her party’s leaders Saturday midday. Bhutto has only recently returned to Pakistan, following a deal with Musharraf. Her brief confinement has probably increased her credibility without damaging her chances of making a deal with Musharraf; indeed, it is reported that talks between the two are continuing. (Bhutto's by no means the only woman to have endured house arrest this last week; see Diane's post below.)

Meanwhile in Burma/Myanmar, Aung San Suu Kyi (see here and here) has been under house arrest for 12 of the past 18 years, and hasn’t met with members of her party, the National League for Democracy, since 2004. Yesterday, she was allowed to do so to discuss the preconditions the military junta has set for meeting with her. Though Suu Kyi is not seeking confrontation or regime change, the proposed talks follow on massive demonstrations led by monks ending in a crackdown by the junta in the last days of September. Ibrahim Gambari, the UN representative who has visited Burma/Myanmar twice since then, was apparently “instrumental” in arranging the proposed talks between the junta and Suu Kyi. Talks may lead to a constitutional referendum and election: after 14 years of on-again off-again sessions, in early September a constitutional convention produced guidelines for a constitution. Unfortunately, the guidelines ensure a strong role for the military.

On Musharraf on Lincoln

As discussed in Naomi's excellent post above, Gen. Pervez Musharraf has called upon the spirit of Abraham Lincoln in an effort to justify declaring a state of emergency in Pakistan.
The invocation of Lincoln (right), the President who governed America at a time when its States were not United -- who saw a 4-year Civil War to its end in 1865 -- has taken the blogosphere by storm. With a hat tip to New York Times blogger Robert Mackey, that segment of Musharraf's speech is available in video above. Full text of the speech is here; here's what Musharraf (below) said about Lincoln:
I would at this time venture to read out an excerpt of President Abraham Lincoln, specially to all my listeners in the United States. As an idealist, Abraham Lincoln had one consuming passion during that time of crisis, and this was to preserve the Union… towards that end, he broke laws, he violated the Constitution, he usurped arbitrary power, he trampled individual liberties. His justification was necessity and explaining his sweeping violation of Constitutional limits he wrote in a letter in 1864, and I quote, 'My oath to preserve the Constitution imposed on me the duty of preserving by every indispensable means that government, that Nation of which the Constitution was the organic law. Was it possible to lose the Nation and yet preserve the Constitution?'
The transcript's from the post by Mackey, who also links to Lincoln's actual words.
What to say about all this?
1st, with regard to "emergency": Lincoln acted after a sizable portion of his country seceded from the Union, donned uniforms, and made war against Union fortresses within the seceded territories. The situation stands on a different plane from the political demonstrations and occasions of terrorist action that Pakistan's faced these last months. Musharraf's regime well have been under threat, given the awaiting decision on whether his re-election was valid, and the new in-country presence of a longtime political opponent, Benazir Bhutto (left), the woman who seeks once again to become the Pakistan's Prime Minister. But it's basic to the derogation rules Naomi discusses that the threat must be to the nation itself, and not simply to the state regime in power in that nation.
2d, with regard to Pakistan and post-9/11 United States: One senses that Musharraf invokes Lincoln because he cannot invoke Bush; that is, he looks to a U.S. President with unquestioned credibility as a source of justification. Yet even an analogy with President George W. Bush (right) would not well serve. The article of mine that Naomi so kindly cites (like my English-language article Guantánamo) questions whether, and if so, how long, the United States suffered such a threat post-9/11. It further criticizes the Bush Administration for acting as if there were a state of emergency yet refusing to discharge its obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. Those obligations:
-- Give precise and proper notice of what emergency measures it was taking (as Britain, incidentally, did); and
-- Tailor those measures precisely to the threat posed, both by limiting suspensions of liberty to the absolute minimum required and by ending all such suspensions as soon as the political climate
permitted.
3d, with regard to the tailoring, or proportionality, of measures by Musharraf, Bush, and Lincoln: In the U.S. periods under review there was, as there now appears to be in Pakistan, neither any wholesale suspension of the Constitution nor any dismissal of the Supreme Court. It is true that there were in the United States curtailments of recourse to habeas corpus. As we've posted, Lincoln's abrogation of the writ remains controversial to this day, and may well prove a point of discussion during the December 5 oral argument before the Supreme Court in the Boumediene challenge to Bush's Guantánamo detention policy. Yet in neither period did U.S. emergency measures go much further than that. It is true that Bush has sought to stave off judicial review of his measures, and in the Detainee Treatment Act and Military Commissions Act Congress has tried to helped him keep the courts at bay. Yet even when the U.S. judiciary brushed aside those efforts, as did the Supreme Court in Hamdan, neither political branch has suggested anything like shutting down the courts. Nor did Chief Justice Roger B. Taney's clash with Lincoln over habeas corpus result in dismissal of Taney (left) or any other member of the Court.
Try as he might, Musharraf can find no refuge in the words of American Presidents, present or past.

Pakistan

This headline in the Hindustan Times says it all: "Karachi carnage mars Bhutto's return." Indeed, "two explosions killed 134 people and wounded 450," the New York Times writes, adding that the "explosions took place just feet from a truck in which Ms. Bhutto was traveling during a triumphal procession marking her return to Pakistan after eight years in exile."
IntLawGrrls've posted often about Bhutto, the 1st woman to serve as Prime Minister in a Muslim country (though perhaps not the 1st PM twice to be deposed on charges of corruption) and her efforts to seek a 3d term. Given recent turmoil in the country, ruled since 1999 by Gen. Pervez Musharraf, yesterday's tragedy is not entirely a surprise. But it calls for questions about Pakistan's security forces, forces whose conduct, painstakingly detailed in Ghost Wars (2004), Steve Coll's Pulitzer Prizewinning study of pre-September 11 counterterrorism practices, remains controversial enough recently to have played a role in Musharraf's effort to oust Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry and to have forced Pakistani author Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa to flee her country. Despite reputed ruthlessness, security forces did not prevent yesterday's tragedy. No surprise, either, then, that Bhutto, who says that days ago she gave Musharraf names of those plotting against her, today is raising questions.

On October 12, ...

... 1915, amid World War I, Edith Cavell was executed by a German firing squad at the National Rifle Range in Brussels. The killing of Cavell, right, a 50-year-old British nurse working in Belgium under the auspices of the Red Cross, followed her conviction for having harbored and aided the escape of Allied soldiers.
... 1999, The Chief of the Army, Gen. Pervez Musharraf, seized control of Pakistan in a bloodless coup that ousted Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif. Eventually Musharraf was elected President, while Sharif and another former Prime Minister, Benazir Bhutto, went into exile. The country's been in turmoil this year, as we've posted. Last Saturday Musharraf won a new term in an election that The Economist condemns as "[u]nrepresentative, rigged and at gunpoint." And though Musharraf managed in September to rebuff Sharif's attempt to return from exile, his bids to fend off Bhutto's promise to come home Oct. 18 seem not to be nearly as successful.

Bhutto in her own words

If you've been following politics in Pakistan, as IntLawGrrls has here, you know that former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto (left) is on the verge of returning home -- and that General/President Pervez Musharraf's less than thrilled at the prospect.
Bhutto tells why she's about to end self-exile in this Huffington Post essay. Her bottom line's a political PR classic:
I didn't choose this life. It chose me.

Writer on the run

On reading our post about Benazir Bhutto's wish to return to Pakistan, our colleague Anil Kalhan kindly pointed us to his own commentary on the country at the latest addition to our "connections" list, Dorf on Law. We've highlighted tumult over the suspension of Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudry in the wake of his criticism of disappearances, and Anil has focused on that as well (here and here). Still, he'd direct our attention to governmental unrest respecting the publication of Military, Inc., an instantly banned book about "the lucrative business interests that feed the Pakistan Army's power," written by Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa (left), a security analyst and 2004 recipient of a Woodrow Wilson Centre fellowship. Anil writes:
Not to diminish the high drama over the Chief Justice, but to me the real sleeper story in there is the story of Dr. Siddiqa -- her book on the Pakistan Army's business interests brings a taboo subject out into the open, and the government seems to have wasted no time in getting the book off the shelves.
Yesterday, the same day as our latest post on the plight of women journalists, Siddiqa left Islamabad for London, having receiving information that if she remained in Islamabad she soon might have to stand trial on charges related to her book.
Thanks, Anil, for this tip; we'll keep eyes open as all this unfolds.

Benazir Bhutto wants to go home

Following on the recent post respecting women leaders, check out this profile of Benazir Bhutto (right), once and would-be future Prime Minister of Pakistan. Charges of corruption and misconduct marred the previous tenures of Bhutto, in "self-imposed exile" for 8 years. Nonetheless, turmoil in the country, stemming in part from the suspension of Pakistan's Chief Justice and in part from the continuing challenge of extremism, seems to have given her an opening for negotiating a return.
 
Bloggers Team