Showing posts with label Combatant Status Review Tribunal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Combatant Status Review Tribunal. Show all posts

1st court-released Gitmo detainees go home

This week has seen the end of a long and painful journey for three of Guantánamo Bay’s most well-known detainees.
This Tuesday Mustafa Ait Idir (right), Hadj Boudella, and Mohamed Nechla returned to their adopted homeland of Bosnia and Herzegovina after spending six years in U.S. custody as “enemy combatants.” The men, together with their compatriots Saber Lahmar, Lakhdar Boumediene and Belkacem Bensayah, were at the center of the U.S. Supreme Court’s latest rejection of the Bush administration’s executive detention policies. In that case, Boumediene v. Bush (discussed earlier here), the Court upheld the petitioners’ right to challenge their detention under the constitutional privilege of habeas corpus and ruled that the government’s Combatant Status Review Tribunals were inadequate substitutes for habeas review. In remand proceedings last month, Judge Richard Leon, of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, ordered the government to release all but Bensayah, on the ground that there was insufficient evidence to justify their continued detention.
The U.S. Department of Defense announced the transfer of Idir, Boudella and Nechla in a terse statement this Tuesday, after which the men were flown to the Sarajevo airport. There they were debriefed by local authorities and reunited with their families, with whom they have had no contact for at least six years.
Upon his return to Bosnia, Idir had this to say about his detention in Guantánamo:
For almost seven years, I was at the end of the world, at the worst place in the world. It would have been hard even if I had done something wrong (but) it is much harder if one is totally innocent.
All six men had been transferred to U.S. custody in 2002, under suspicion of plotting to attack the U.S. embassy in Sarajevo -- despite the fact they they had been acquitted of those very same charges just months earlier by the Supreme Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Unhappy with that outcome, in 2002 U.S. officials pressured Bosnian authorities to surrender the men or risk losing American presence in their country. Three of the six men had remained in continued executive detention until Tuesday.
Boumediene (right) and Lahmar are still at Guantánamo, awaiting release.

News From Guantánamo

This last week has seen two developments in Guantanamo litigation, both in the U.S. federal court and in the U.S. Military Commissions:
United States v. Jawad (Mil. Comm. Jan 31, 2008)
The Defense Department announced that charges were referred to a military commission in the case of Mohammed Jawad by the Convening Authority, Office of Military Commissions, Susan J. Crawford. Jawad was charged with attempted murder in violation of the law of war and intentionally causing serious bodily injury. It is alleged that he attempted to commit murder and cause serious bodily injury by throwing a hand grenade into the passenger compartment of a vehicle transporting two U.S. Army military personnel and their interpreter with the intent to kill them. In accordance with the Military Commissions Act of 2006 and the Manual for Military Commissions, Jawad will be brought before the military trial judge for arraignment within 30 days of the service of charges. Within 120 days of the referral, the military trial judge will assemble the military commission.
Brig. Gen. Thomas Hartmann, legal advisor to the convening authority, claimed that these war crime proceedings will continue to move forward in open trials and with more due process than any alleged war criminal has historically received. Many JAG defense lawyers assigned to represent Guantanamo detainees charged with war crimes and the international legal community contend that the military commissions procedures are inherently unfair and contrary to international law and military justice.
Of the 275 detainees at Guantanamo, approximately 80 are expected to face trial by military commission.
Bismullah v. Gates (D.C. Cir. Feb. 1, 2008)
The D.C. Circuit denied en banc review in Bismullah, the lead case with respect to D.C. Circuit review of the Combatant Status Review Tribunal determinations of enemy combatant status (the adequacy of which is a central issue before the Supreme Court in Boumediene). The Circuit split 5 to 5 on the question of whether to grant rehearing en banc, and thus denied the petition. Chief Judge Douglas Ginsburg issued an opinion, essentially restating the position, articulated in the panel opinion at issue, that a DTA (Detainee Treatment Act) revoew requires the Circuit to have access to all of the information in the government's possession relating to the detainee’s status as an enemy combatant, not just the information the Tribunal reviewed in finding the detainee to be an enemy combatant, in order to determine whether the CSRT Recorder discharged his duty to assemble such information. Judges Henderson and Randolph each wrote dissenting opinions, joined by Sentelle and Kavanaugh, arguing that the D.C. Circuit’s review of a CSRT determination should not require production of information that was not part of the record before the CSRT itself, or at least that this question should be decided by the full circuit.
For a more detailed explanation of how the Detainee Treatment Act and the Military Commissions Act affect the Combatant Status Review Tribunals and the Administrative Review Boards (two military procedures that the Guantanamo detainees have been provided during their detention), read "Standards and Procedures for Classifying 'Enemy Combatants': Congress, What Have You Done?" by yours truly, IntLawGrrl and Professor Kristine A. Huskey.

Gitmo, round 3

Today the U.S. Supreme Court embarked on its 3d voyage in 3 years to Guantánamo Bay.
Justices convened at 10 to hear an hour of oral argument in Boumediene v. Bush, the title for consolidated cases brought by many of the noncitizens whom executive officials seized abroad in the years since 9/11 and then transported to the naval base that the United States has operated for more than a century at the southeastern corner of the island of Cuba.
Arguing on behalf of detainees were Seth P. Waxman, who served as Solicitor General, the United States' chief appellate attorney, from 1997-2001 and is now a D.C.-based private practitioner. Arguing on behalf of the government was Paul D. Clement, the current Solicitor General.
As detailed in briefs about which IntLawGrrl and amicus author Beth Van Schaack* has posted, discussion promised to cover both jurisdictional and merits issues. Preargument, these seemed like likely key concerns:
1st, may U.S. courts consider legal challenges brought by these detainees? In Rasul v. Bush (2004), 1 of 3 judgments in the 1st round of Gitmo litigation, the Court ruled that nothing in the federal habeas statute precluded so extending the "privilege of litigation." Congress responded by rewriting the statute, not just once but, after the Court rebuffed the 1st attempt in Hamdan v. Rumsfeld (2006) -- Gitmo, round 2 -- twice. With regard to that 2d effort, contained in the Military Commissions Act, the Court will determine whether Congress indeed intended to curtail federal litigation and, if so, whether the Constitution permits such curtailment.
2d, assuming that the litigation may go forward, do the special military panels set up in the wake of the 2004 judgments satisfy legal requirements for reviewing the lawfulness of detention? Evidence supporting petitioners' contention that the panels are procedurally deficient and unduly skewed toward the government's side have come from a number of sources, among them the Denbeaux studies of CSRT transcripts and, at the appendix to this filing, an affidavit from officer who served on those panels.
UPDATE: The Court's now released to the internet both an audio tape and written transcript of this morning's argument. For a roundup on commentary so far, see SCOTUSblog.

* Other IntLawGrrls with a hand in today's arguments: Amicus author Jenny S. Martinez, and Kristine A. Huskey, whose representation of certain detainees is described here. Have I forgotten anyone?

Al-Odah & Boumediene Petitioners

After a flurry of filing on Friday, briefing by Petitioners in the Al-Odah and Boumediene cases (consolidated on certiorari) closed. The merits briefs and a sizable number of amicus curiae briefs are available on the Mayer, Brown, Rowe & Maw website. An impressive array of amici filed briefs in support of Petitioners, including the U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights; European and Canadian parliamentarians; constitutional, federal jurisdiction, human rights, and humanitarian law experts and scholars, including former ICRC principals; Amnesty International; retired and former federal judges, diplomats, and military officers; the ABA; and the National Institute of Military Justice.
As discussed in prior posts (here, here, here, and here), the case presents the question, among others, of whether the Military Commission Act of 2006 (MCA) unconstitutionally suspended the writ of habeas corpus in violation of the Suspension Clause, which states:

The Privilege of the Writ of Habeas Corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in Cases of Rebellion or Invasion the public Safety may require it.

The MCA purportedly barred the writ for pending cases wherein it states:
No court, justice, or judge shall have jurisdiction to hear or consider an application for a writ of habeas corpus filed by or on behalf of an alien detained by the U.S. who has been determined by the U.S. to have been properly detained as an enemy combatant or is awaiting such determination.

In prior proceedings, the government argued that the historic writ of habeas corpus would not have extended to alien enemy combatants held extraterritorially, so the MCA works no “suspension” within the meaning of the Constitution. This is notwithstanding that the Court in Rasul v. Bush, 542 U.S. 466, 480 (2004), clearly ruled that Guantánamo was within the territorial jurisdiction of the United States and that the writ did extend to Petitioners. Id. at 481-82. In the alternative, the Government has argued that Petitioners—as aliens outside sovereign U.S. territory—have no constitutional rights. Petitioners have responded that the Suspension Clause—situated in Article 1 of the Constitution—creates no individual rights, bur rather is a structural constraint on Congress providing

constitutional protection to a preexisting right founded in the common law: the right to obtain independent judicial review of a detention to ensure that no person is deprived of liberty by the Executive without a satisfactory basis in law and fact.

Al-Odah v. United States, Brief For Petitioners El-Banna et al.
Following the Supreme Court’s holding in Rasul v. Bush, the Department of Defense convened Combatant Status Review Tribunals (CSRTs) to determine whether an individual could be detained as an “enemy combatant.” The Department also established Administrative Review Boards (ARBs) to meet annually to determine whether this designation still holds. The Al-Odah & Boumediene cases also present the question of whether the CSRTs and ARBs provide an adequate substitute for habeas corpus where they provide only limited rights of participation and confrontation, deny the right to counsel, admit evidence procured by torture and coercion, admit hearsay and other evidence that would otherwise be inadmissible, are apparently subject to command influence, and are not subject to plenary review on appeal. Testimony from former CSRT participants about these procedural flaws in the process, including Lt. Col. Stephen Abraham (upper left, photo by Chris Carlson/NPR), probably led to the Supreme Court reversing its original denial of certiorari in the cases.
Stay tuned for the government's briefs....

[by IntLawGrrl Beth Van Schaack, under her pen name Eleanor Roosevelt]

GTMOre news

With so much happening, where to begin a counterterrorism update? Let's start with these 5 items relating to executive detention, then move in due course to Globally Disappeared and Accountability at Home and Abroad.

Item No. 1. Another call for Gitmo closure -- this time from Colin Powell (below), U.S. Secretary of State when the camp opened in 2002 -- came yesterday on "Meet the Press":

If it was up to me I'd close Guantánamo, not tomorrow, but this afternoon. I'd close it. And I would not let any of those people go. I would simply move them to the United States and put them and put them into our federal legal system. The concern was, 'Well, then they'll have access to lawyers. Then they'll have access to writs of habeas corpus.' So what? Let them. Isn't that what our system's all about? And by the way, America has, unfortunately, 2 million people in jail, all of whom had access to lawyers and access writs of habeas corpus. And so we can handle bad people in our system. And so I would get rid of Guantánamo and I'd get rid of the military commission system, and use established procedures in federal law or in the Manual for Courts-Martial. I would do that because I think it's a more equitable way to do it and it's more understandable in constitutional terms.
But I would also do it because every morning I pick up a paper, and some authoritarian figure, some person somewhere is using Guantánamo to hide their own misdeeds. And so essentially we have shaken the belief that the world had in America's justice system by keeping a place like Guantánamo open and creating things like the military commission. We don't need it, and it's causing us far more damage than any good we get for it.
But, remember when I started this discussion, saying, 'Don't let any of them go. Put them into a different system, a system that is experienced and knows how to handle people like this.'

Item No. 2. As posted, the commissions of which Powell spoke were halted after 2 military judges held themselves without jurisdiction to hear cases brought before them. The ruling's fueled challenges in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. The 1st is on behalf of Salim Ahmed Hamdan, an en banc challenge to the commissions (N.B. Judge Allred's issued a revised order linking dismissal in Hamdan to Judge Robertson's reasoning at 344 F. Supp. 2d 152, 156 (D.D.C. 2004). The 2d is on behalf of other detainees, challenges to the Combatant Status Review Tribunals designed to precede any trial proceedings. And even before the military judges ruled, the Supreme Court had invited a U.S. response to petitions, in Boumediene and Al Odah, for rehearing of the Court's decision not to grant immediate review of detainee challenges to channeling of habeas review implemented as a result of the Military Commissions Act of 2007. (Go-to sites for news and documents on these developments: SCOTUSblog and National Institute of Military Justice.)

Item No. 3. This morning the 4th Circuit granted habeas to Ali Saleh Kahlah al-Marri, the only known "enemy combatant" designee held on U.S. soil. Rejecting the Bush Administration's invocation of the MCA's habeas strip, the majority opinion by Judge Diana Gribbon Motz (left) remanded the case to the trial court

with instructions to issue a writ of habeas corpus directing the Secretary of Defense to release al-Marri from military custody within a reasonable period .... The Government can transfer al-Marri to civilian authorities to face criminal charges, initiate deportation proceedings against him, hold him as a material witness in connection with grand jury proceedings, or detain him for a limited time pursuant to the Patriot Act. But military detention of al-Marri must cease.

Item No. 4. Habeas has been on Congress' agenda too: by an 11-8 vote late last week the Senate Judiciary Committee approved the Habeas Restoration Act (S. 185), which would undo the MCA's habeas strip. The bill is expected to reach the full Senate later in the month.

Item No. 5. Finally, Powell's catchall characterization of all detainees as "bad people" was off the mark. It's by no means an accurate label for all the 700 boys and men who've passed through Guantánamo (where, incidentally, a 4th suicide occurred 2 weeks ago almost without remark). A sad reminder of that fact is the fate of nearly 2 dozen Chinese nationals of Uighur ethnicity who, after years in executive detention, were found to pose no threat to the United States. But they couldn't be returned to China because of the possibility they would suffer harm there, and no country would grant them asylum save Albania, where life this last year has been "driving them to desperation." “Sometimes,'" 1 of them told the New York Times, "'we think it would be better to go die in our homeland than to stay here.'”

Gitmo judge tosses Khadr case

Paraphrasing Justice John Paul Stevens' opinion for the Court in Hamdan v. Rumsfeld as follows -- "'A person has a right to be tried only by a court that has jurisdiction over him.'" -- a military judge just threw out the U.S. government's case against alleged child soldier Omar Khadr. The 3-page order of Judge Peter E. Brownback III, an Army colonel, has been posted here by the National Institute of Military Justice. Decision turned on the fact that § 948d of the Military Commissions Act passed post-Hamdan gives the commission jurisdiction only over an "alien unlawful enemy combatant." A Combatant Status Review Tribunal convened in 2004, 2 years before enactment of the MCA, found that Khadr was an "enemy combatant" but made no distinction as to lawfulness or unlawfulness of that status. Brownback wrote (¶ 11):
The military judge is not ruling that no facts could be properly established concerning Mr. Khadr which might fit the definition of an unlawful enemy combatant .... The military judge is ruling that the military commission is not the proper authority, under the provisions of the MCA, to determine that Mr. Khadr is an unlawful enemy combatant in order to establish initial jurisdiction for this commission to try Mr. Khadr.
Although Brownback left open the possibility of refiling of charges following a proper determination, Marine Corps Col. Dwight Sullivan, Chief Defense Counsel at Gitmo, said:
'The system right now should just stop. The commission is an experiment that failed, and we don't need any more evidence that it is a failure.'
 
Bloggers Team